Comments Thread For: Daily Bread Mailbag: What next for Tim Tszyu, more on Artur Beterbiev-Dmitry Bivol, and the future of Kyrone Davis

[Poopdick]

What is your understanding of p4p? Just curious

it would start with a guy massively undersized and beating top 4 or 5 guys in that division. after moving up from a division he wiped out and was undisputed in. and that division didn't have pushover either. and anyone likes the route of sizing these guys to a same weight size, he would beat Crawford and Inoue and anyone else

[BrankoB]

It is pointless arguing and getting frustrated about p4p. It is hypothetical, highly subjective and for the most part can never be validated in the ring (except for the guys on that list that actually fight each other). Others are too far apart in weight like Inoue and Usyk so you can never measure it. It is subjective and comes down to who do you like. Well, we all like and appreciate different styles, qualities etc so there can never be a consensus on that list. I mean, for a start who on earth publishes 1a, 1b and 1c - that in itself is a highly customised, unorthodox and subjective.

[billeau2]

It is pointless arguing and getting frustrated about p4p. It is hypothetical, highly subjective and for the most part can never be validated in the ring (except for the guys on that list that actually fight each other). Others are too far apart in weight like Inoue and Usyk so you can never measure it. It is subjective and comes down to who do you like. Well, we all like and appreciate different styles, qualities etc so there can never be a consensus on that list. I mean, for a start who on earth publishes 1a, 1b and 1c - that in itself is a highly customised, unorthodox and subjective.

All these big nothing burgers. They just make people argue. The best way to compare fighters is to let them fight in the ring.

[tokon]

It is pointless arguing and getting frustrated about p4p. It is hypothetical, highly subjective and for the most part can never be validated in the ring (except for the guys on that list that actually fight each other). Others are too far apart in weight like Inoue and Usyk so you can never measure it. It is subjective and comes down to who do you like. Well, we all like and appreciate different styles, qualities etc so there can never be a consensus on that list. I mean, for a start who on earth publishes 1a, 1b and 1c - that in itself is a highly customised, unorthodox and subjective.

Amen.

1a, b, c is a cop out imo

[The D3vil]

Inoue ok ,but Crawford is an absolute joke as 1,tribalism is a real thing

Dude, Beterbiev called Crawford the P4P king & Bivol said Bud has a higher ring IQ than Canelo.

Y'all just be saying anything on the internet