Which of these heavyweights should retire?

[Bigdaddy_Vh]

Holyfield, McCall, Mercer, Briggs should retire. The rest could serve as gatekeepers for up and comers with the exception of Tua and Toney who could at least hold their own against marginal opposition(with Tua probably having a punchers chance of beating anyone)

[Panamaniac]

All! Starting with the top of the list.

[onedream722]

almost that whole list

[joe strong]

I always wanted to see Holyfield vs. Mccall.

Maybe they should all have a tournament?

Let's see, who would win a tournament out of all them guy's?

Make that a poll!

I say toney over tua by decision if that tourney took place.good post & great idea!

[Glamour Puss]

All of them. And throw Monty Barrets ass in there too.

[INFAMOUZ]

James toney ,evander david tua rey mercer they too old they should hang there gloves

[IEsickboy]

John Ruiz should be at the top of the list

[Johnny Rebel]

Holyfield. It's really sad watching a legend getting punch drunk...

[The Hammer]

All of them. And throw Monty Barrets ass in there too.

Yes, Monte looked old and shot on Saturday.

[Davros?]

Holyfield, Toney, Rahman, Maskaev, Mercer and Briggs