Why is Floyd in the top 5 at WW?

[Glamour Puss]

When he never beat a top 5 or even top 10 WW for that matter.

Carlos Baldomir was a fluke and everyone knows it.

Until Floyd fights and beats a legit top 5 WW it should look like this:

1)Mosley
2)Margarito
3)Cotto
4)Clottey
5)Cintron/Williams (if they're at 47' at the time)

[Grand Champ]

Because he dominated a lightweight... DOOOOH!!!

[firstborn]

Because most boxer's will admit that he has the most talent. He's a cherry picker but almost any pro boxer will tell you that he's in the top three. Only haters refuse to admit it.

[Pretty Boy Greg]

When he never beat a top 5 or even top 10 WW for that matter.

Carlos Baldomir was a fluke and everyone knows it.

Until Floyd fights and beats a legit top 5 WW it should look like this:

1)Mosley
2)Margarito
3)Cotto
4)Clottey
5)Cintron/Williams (if they're at 47' at the time)

ahhh probably because he beat baldy which was #1 and then judah who was #2! move on to something new hater!!! check out horus's new forum on lineal champions

[-EX-]

Baldomir and Judah were in the top 10 at welterweight when Floyd fought them...and Judah is ranked #3 by the WBA...

[Doctor_Tenma]

Yeah and why does Shane want to fight a WW who isn't ranked in the top 5?

[DrewWoodside]

When he never beat a top 5 or even top 10 WW for that matter.

Carlos Baldomir was a fluke and everyone knows it.

Until Floyd fights and beats a legit top 5 WW it should look like this:

1)Mosley
2)Margarito
3)Cotto
4)Clottey
5)Cintron/Williams (if they're at 47' at the time)

I don't think Baldomir was necessarily a fluke.. but it was years ago and he wasn't particularly special. Here's a similar topic I made that had a lot of interesting info on the subject:
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=308471

[Pretty Boy Greg]

Baldomir and Judah were in the top 10 at welterweight when Floyd fought them...and Judah is ranked #3 by the WBA...

wasnt mitchell ranked 7th??

[-EX-]

Ring Magazine ranking from 2006 at 147

WELTERWEIGHTS
Weight Limit: 147 pounds
C C 23 CARLOS BALDOMIR 42-9-6 (12)
1 1 7 FLOYD MAYWEATHER 36-0 (24)
2 2 254 ANTONIO MARGARITO 33-4 (24)
3 3 106 ZAB JUDAH 34-4 (25)
4 4 2 RICKY HATTON 41-0 (30)
5 5 58 LUIS COLLAZO 26-1 (12)
6 6 17 ARTURO GATTI 40-7 (31)
7 7 95 KERMIT CINTRON 25-1 (23)
8 8 63 JOSE ANTONIO RIVERA 37-4-1 (24)
9 9 52 OKTAY URKAL 36-3 (11)
10 10 321 THOMAS DAMGAARD 37-1 (27)

Of course that was before Floyd beat Baldomir...

[Pretty Boy Greg]

Yeah and why does Shane want to fight a WW who isn't ranked in the top 5?

rankings don't mean crap anymore to Floyd!!! he can fight whomever he wants now and you can take that to the bank!