Why is Floyd in the top 5 at WW?

[iHateThePacMan]

When he never beat a top 5 or even top 10 WW for that matter.

Carlos Baldomir was a fluke and everyone knows it.

Until Floyd fights and beats a legit top 5 WW it should look like this:

1)Mosley
2)Margarito
3)Cotto
4)Clottey
5)Cintron/Williams (if they're at 47' at the time)

Because he dominated JMM who is a smaller guy.

[Horus]

Ring Magazine ranking from 2006 at 147

WELTERWEIGHTS
Weight Limit: 147 pounds
C C 23 CARLOS BALDOMIR 42-9-6 (12)
1 1 7 FLOYD MAYWEATHER 36-0 (24)
2 2 254 ANTONIO MARGARITO 33-4 (24)
3 3 106 ZAB JUDAH 34-4 (25)
4 4 2 RICKY HATTON 41-0 (30)
5 5 58 LUIS COLLAZO 26-1 (12)
6 6 17 ARTURO GATTI 40-7 (31)
7 7 95 KERMIT CINTRON 25-1 (23)
8 8 63 JOSE ANTONIO RIVERA 37-4-1 (24)
9 9 52 OKTAY URKAL 36-3 (11)
10 10 321 THOMAS DAMGAARD 37-1 (27)

Of course that was before Floyd beat Baldomir...

TOO MANY FACTS....

just read this thread for some amazing facts about boxingscene and floyd

Horus Presents: TOP 48 MOST MEMORABLE MAYWEATHER THREADS
http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=271721

[Pretty Boy Greg]

When he never beat a top 5 or even top 10 WW for that matter.

Carlos Baldomir was a fluke and everyone knows it.

Until Floyd fights and beats a legit top 5 WW it should look like this:

1)Mosley
2)Margarito
3)Cotto
4)Clottey
5)Cintron/Williams (if they're at 47' at the time)

First off marge the cheater should never get a big fight ever again, especially after what he did to cotton and pwill is not a WW and if he beats pavlik he will not ever be back to WW, mark my words!! Cintron is a dead man walking that moved to JMW division because lets face it, that division sucks!!! you need to include at least berto and collazo up there if you are going to be a ******* nuthugger and say pbf doesn't belong in the top 5!!