What Is A Robbery? Devin Haney - Vasyl Lomachenko Scored By Unbaised Artificial Intelligence.

Collapse
This topic is closed.
X
X
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Cypocryphy
    I DISPUTE YOUR UNDISPUTED
    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
    • Apr 2020
    • 4656
    • 1,633
    • 1,425
    • 14,834

    #1

    What Is A Robbery? Devin Haney - Vasyl Lomachenko Scored By Unbaised Artificial Intelligence.



    After the fight, many rewatched it (some several times) and decided they were initially wrong, that Haney did win the fight. Just today (which is why I thought I'd make this post), I heard Brad Goodman say he scored the fight for Loma at first, but on his second time viewing, he scored it for Devin (116-112).

    Do you think Goodman and others are right? What do you guys think? Was this actually a robbery?

    Let's see what an unbiased, extremely accurate AI tells us ....

    Additionally, I'm curious as to what the forum believes constitutes a robbery. Is it how many rounds a boxer wins and isn't given credit for? Is it how dominate he was? People seem to have different thresholds.
  • _Rexy_
    Undisputed Champion
    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
    • Jan 2018
    • 27929
    • 6,140
    • 3,585
    • 358,040

    #2
    Did they produce a scorecard? I don't have time to watch 45 minutes right now. I skipped to the end though and was surprised to see the 12th was closer than I thought at the time. (significantly closer than I had remembered)

    Comment

    • paulf
      Undisputed Champion
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Sep 2009
      • 23719
      • 3,326
      • 2,096
      • 1,052,140

      #3
      Loma got going too late. Let it go, y’all

      Comment

      • Cypocryphy
        I DISPUTE YOUR UNDISPUTED
        Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
        • Apr 2020
        • 4656
        • 1,633
        • 1,425
        • 14,834

        #4
        Originally posted by _Rexy_
        Did they produce a scorecard? I don't have time to watch 45 minutes right now. I skipped to the end though and was surprised to see the 12th was closer than I thought at the time. (significantly closer than I had remembered)
        Yeah. Here's DeepStrikes Scorecard:

        DEEPSTRIKE
        DEVIN HANEY VASYL LOMACHENKO
        1 10 9
        2 9 10
        3 9 10
        4 9 10
        5 9 10
        6 9 10
        7 9 10
        8 9 10
        9 9 10
        10 9 10
        11 9 10
        12 10 9
        TOTAL: 110 118

        Comment

        • Spray_resistant
          Vacant interim regular(C)
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Feb 2009
          • 29219
          • 2,734
          • 1,452
          • 53,384

          #5
          A robbery to me is one fighter clearly and decisively winning at least 8 of 12 rds and doesn't get the decision. Boxing is subjective and 7-5 leaves too much doubt even if it appears they clearly won. I am discounting kds so lets say they need to be a minimum of 4 points ahead.

          In the case of Loma/Haney, neither fighter clearly won more than 1 or 2 rds, it was a close highly contested chess match and I am ok with Haney getting the nod but will respect anyone's opinion that Loma won close.

          Comment

          • Cypocryphy
            I DISPUTE YOUR UNDISPUTED
            Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
            • Apr 2020
            • 4656
            • 1,633
            • 1,425
            • 14,834

            #6
            Originally posted by _Rexy_
            Did they produce a scorecard? I don't have time to watch 45 minutes right now. I skipped to the end though and was surprised to see the 12th was closer than I thought at the time. (significantly closer than I had remembered)
            BTW, you could make an argument that Loma had a 10-8 round in round 11. He kicked the crap out of Devin that round, landing 21 punches to Devins five, 11 of which were power punches.

            Comment

            • Cypocryphy
              I DISPUTE YOUR UNDISPUTED
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Apr 2020
              • 4656
              • 1,633
              • 1,425
              • 14,834

              #7
              Originally posted by Spray_resistant
              A robbery to me is one fighter clearly and decisively winning at least 8 of 12 rds and doesn't get the decision. Boxing is subjective and 7-5 leaves too much doubt even if it appears they clearly won. I am discounting kds so lets say they need to be a minimum of 4 points ahead.

              In the case of Loma/Haney, neither fighter clearly won more than 1 or 2 rds, it was a close highly contested chess match and I am ok with Haney getting the nod but will respect anyone's opinion that Loma won close.
              Artificial intelligence assessed the fight, and tallied all the punches. It was pretty clear that Loma won 10 rounds. By your standards, that would be considered a robbery. You can watch how it was scored.

              Comment

              • Spray_resistant
                Vacant interim regular(C)
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Feb 2009
                • 29219
                • 2,734
                • 1,452
                • 53,384

                #8
                Originally posted by Cypocryphy

                Artificial intelligence assessed the fight, and tallied all the punches. It was pretty clear that Loma won 10 rounds. By your standards, that would be considered a robbery. You can watch how it was scored.
                We don't score by number of punches, its based primarily of effectiveness of punches which is a judgement call and machine eyes need not apply we only like emotional subjective flesh and blood types round these parts.

                Comment

                • Cypocryphy
                  I DISPUTE YOUR UNDISPUTED
                  Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                  • Apr 2020
                  • 4656
                  • 1,633
                  • 1,425
                  • 14,834

                  #9
                  Originally posted by Spray_resistant

                  We don't score by number of punches, its based primarily of effectiveness of punches which is a judgement call and machine eyes need not apply we only like emotional subjective flesh and blood types round these parts.
                  Clearly you haven't watched the video. I'm telling everyone that this DeepStrike AI will revolutionize the sport. It has a five-tiered scale that measures how hard the punches are, from minimum to maximum. Moreover, it assesses ring general and effective aggression by judging pressure and aggression. This is not just tallying punches. This is telling you who won the fight. This will change how fights are scored and ensure that the right man wins.

                  I recommend you watch it before commenting.

                  Comment

                  • Spray_resistant
                    Vacant interim regular(C)
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Feb 2009
                    • 29219
                    • 2,734
                    • 1,452
                    • 53,384

                    #10
                    Originally posted by Cypocryphy

                    Clearly you haven't watched the video. I'm telling everyone that this DeepStrike AI will revolutionize the sport. It has a five-tiered scale that measures how hard the punches are, from minimum to maximum. Moreover, it assesses ring general and effective aggression by judging pressure and aggression. This is not just tallying punches. This is telling you who won the fight. This will change how fights are scored and ensure that the right man wins.

                    I recommend you watch it before commenting.
                    I took a look, I'm not going to watch the whole thing but get the premise and don't like it. Its over complicated for no reason, we can all see what lands and judge the effectiveness of the punches.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP