If Hopkins / Calzaghe rematched ...

[Sir Tom Jones]

Calzaghe probably beats him again. Prime Hopkins beats Prime Joe though. Here come the fanboys.

when was this prime hopkins that would beat joe?

[daggum]

when was this prime hopkins that would beat joe?

will a 43 year old calzaghe be able to beat anyone in the p4p list? when he does then we can compare how they would do against each other.

[Walterson]

Calzaghe by Decision. A fair bit wider this time though.

the same could be said for Hopkins?

[Walterson]

will a 43 year old calzaghe be able to beat anyone in the p4p list? when he does then we can compare how they would do against each other.

good statement!

[daggum]

It would be the same result.

In their prime it would always be a close fight IMO, depends what the judges prefer.

i agree do the judges prefer clean punching, defense, effective agression, or do they use their own rules which would enable calzaghe to win. things like swarming ineffectively, wasting punches, taking a punch well, etc...

[nachorjj]

I think that Bernard with out Roach and with his traineer put KO in 5 rounds with out problems

[Walterson]

Let's all remember folks that Calzaghe won the first fight based on being the aggressor.

[rskumm21]

Hopkins would win again.

[Walterson]

I think that Bernard with out Roach and with his traineer put KO in 5 rounds with out problems

good statement.

[Walterson]

Hopkins would win again.

good statement.