Comments Thread For: James: Charlo Would Have To Be Considered One Of Greatest P4P All Time If He Beats Canelo

[JJ75JJ]

No sir. Bivol fought a smaller Alvarez. Bivol had the size advantage and had exactly 1 title.

Charlo is undisputed at his weight and is giving up 14 lbs to Alvarez. These wins are going to be vastly different (if Charlo gets it done)

I already think Charlo deserves to be on the p4p list, but him going up to fight Canelo like this and winning will have him as number 1 on my list for damn sure. Most people had Usyk top 5 when he was still a cruiser and that was the only division he ever competed in. Had Spence top 5 and he only competed at WW. I will be giving Charlo his props if he pulls this off.

Imagine believing Charlo has a chance against Canelo. Bruh Charlo is all washed up, he won't win another fight.

[Rebelrbg]

No sir. Bivol fought a smaller Alvarez. Bivol had the size advantage and had exactly 1 title.

Charlo is undisputed at his weight and is giving up 14 lbs to Alvarez. These wins are going to be vastly different (if Charlo gets it done)

I already think Charlo deserves to be on the p4p list, but him going up to fight Canelo like this and winning will have him as number 1 on my list for damn sure. Most people had Usyk top 5 when he was still a cruiser and that was the only division he ever competed in. Had Spence top 5 and he only competed at WW. I will be giving Charlo his props if he pulls this off.

I completely agree with you

[Smash]

we are truly blessed to be in this era of the GOATS of all time, first Bud demands his status after beating the drunken sailor & now charlo is on the verge if he can just do a job on Mr Yarkstick himself, the one the only Canelo, to be fair moving up 2 divisions to fight someone is tough anyway & would be a great achievement for charlo, i doubt he pulls it off though, canelo i think is on the slide but hes still good

[JLC]

Imagine believing Charlo has a chance against Canelo. Bruh Charlo is all washed up, he won't win another fight.

If he loses he loses. But if he wins he deserves a LOT of credit. Outside of the money aspect it’s likely why he jumped at this fight. He has way more to gain than he has to lose.