Comments Thread For: James: Charlo Would Have To Be Considered One Of Greatest P4P All Time If He Beats Canelo

[_Rexy_]

James loves to talk P4P right before one of his fighters gets dogwalked.

[TheWinners]

All Time??? It ain’t that serious. He would still be behind Crawford, Inoue, Usyk and a couple others if he beat Alvarez. Alvarez himself still needs to revenge his loss to Bivol.

I wouldn't say all time. But he would have to be #1 on the list right now. To come back after a year and 4 mo layoff and beat the undisputed champion 2 weight classes up. That's more impressive than anything Usyk, Crawford, or Inoue did.

[Jab jab boom]

Stop it. Out here acting like he’d be beating a prime Roy Jones or Sugar Ray Leonard.

[jackblack008]

Its funny how a mismatch is being shilled on these forums

[cace]

I wouldn't say all time. But he would have to be #1 on the list right now. To come back after a year and 4 mo layoff and beat the undisputed champion 2 weight classes up. That's more impressive than anything Usyk, Crawford, or Inoue did.

i agree with this

[Tonyu]

I haven't rooted for Canelo since he fought Floyd.

Please Ginger, have enough left in the tank to knock Charlo out. The incredibly ****** interviews, ducking Tyszu, Derrick James saying he will be an all timer if he beats getting past it Canelo.

Hopefully both Charlo's retire soon. The IQ average of the sport will go up 20 points instantly.

Well said, Tim is on a high stopping an opponent relatively easy who defeated Charlo. Charlo took the Canelo fight to avoid Tszyu as losing to Canelo is better than losing to Tim Tszyu. It's surprising because if he really thought he could beat Tszyu he would use that as a warm up fight before having a huge fight against Canelo next year. Canelo should be fighting Benavidez instead who I think will beat Canelo especially as his past his best and Charlo should be honouring his mandatory which his kept on hold.

This P4P list which everyone is talking about if by some miracle Canelo has an off night and loses its not a prime Canelo so number 1 please, Charlo's best win is Harrison who beat him first time around and his never really had a major name and unifying a division that is mediocre at best is not grounds for the no 1 spot but Charlos fans will keep telling themselves that as fans are fickle and live in their own bubble that's why we need a independent body to decide this.

[DJ49]

Lol tell this guy to stop smoking before the interview.

[hugh grant]

It is a massive win jumping up 2 divisions nd as a single challenge and win it's gigantic. But it's only one win. And there's no saying Nell didn't have an off night.
So it's best to judge after fight. If it was the best Nelo we've ever seen of nelo And Nell still loses, then you can have discussion.

[JJ75JJ]

One false premise after another.

Canelo will destroy Charlo, its an enormous mismatch. Ive got Canelo by KO inside of 4 rounds.

[cace]

me too
but it would be one hell of an achievement if he could pull it off