Comments Thread For: Crawford Takes the Lead: BoxingScene P4P Update

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Roadblock
    Undisputed Champion
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • May 2006
    • 14031
    • 3,535
    • 428
    • 108,713

    #21
    Originally posted by hugh grant

    You know the answer. It's a credit to spence that he pulled those wins out of bag that he had enough within himself, shows the talent. But no one's to say those fights didn't take even more out of him? I mean when you've had a knock to the head, you can come down with something peculiar at any given moment have funny turn. One minute your ok, next minute you feel off and even faint.
    I've not even seen the fights, all I know is spence best Garcia and ugas so in my mind he must be fine, but of course that's not the best way to gauge spence.
    Thats all good, but youre not running with something might be wrong with Errol, you are running with there was, and placing TC lower because of that, that's not right because its also said Fulton was not right so you cant run with either excuses for losing, its got to be on face value of the wins. as good as Inoue is he shouldn't be rated above TC, its has many reasons and lot to do with names and WW being the glamour division, you can run all over saying Inoue is No 1, but its not reality and P4P lists is the proof.

    Comment

    • hugh grant
      Undisputed Champion
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Apr 2006
      • 30117
      • 2,146
      • 818
      • 105,596

      #22
      Originally posted by Roadblock

      Thats all good, but youre not running with something might be wrong with Errol, you are running with there was, and placing TC lower because of that, that's not right because its also said Fulton was not right so you cant run with either excuses for losing, its got to be on face value of the wins. as good as Inoue is he shouldn't be rated above TC, its has many reasons and lot to do with names and WW being the glamour division, you can run all over saying Inoue is No 1, but its not reality and P4P lists is the proof.
      But I was actually impressed with fulton. Iniue outclassed him, but Fulton took his hits and mostly didn't show panic, I thought might be long night for inoue, Fulton footwork was good, looked slick, much to admire in fact. In fact I was thinking come on Fulton wince in pain or something your making a mockery of inoues fearsome punched rep.
      Spence on other hand had no balance, looked uncomfortable, opposite to Fulton in fact.

      Comment

      • ShoulderRoll
        Join The Great Resist
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Oct 2009
        • 55911
        • 10,022
        • 5,016
        • 763,445

        #23
        Originally posted by Dean_Razorback

        i love how they talk crap about inoue beating an "old" nonito but say nothing about spence being demolished prior by a deadly car crash or how porter lost every big fight before losing to crawford aswell lol
        Nonito just lost again. He’s old and past it.

        Spence broke Ugas’ face after that deadly car crash.

        Comment

        • GhostofDempsey
          Undisputed Champion
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • Mar 2017
          • 31333
          • 12,917
          • 8,587
          • 493,602

          #24
          Crawford is #1 Inoue #2 Usyk #3 Teo #4 Bivol #5

          Comment

          • Roadblock
            Undisputed Champion
            Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
            • May 2006
            • 14031
            • 3,535
            • 428
            • 108,713

            #25
            Originally posted by hugh grant

            But I was actually impressed with fulton. Iniue outclassed him, but Fulton took his hits and mostly didn't show panic, I thought might be long night for inoue, Fulton footwork was good, looked slick, much to admire in fact. In fact I was thinking come on Fulton wince in pain or something your making a mockery of inoues fearsome punched rep.
            Spence on other hand had no balance, looked uncomfortable, opposite to Fulton in fact.
            You were impressed with Fulton because he never got flogged as easily, that could also mean TC is better than Inoue, you see you are applying a rating based on what your bias is and not what is fact which is they both won easily, one doesn't rate higher because IF both guys are messed up in training you get to claim which is valid. The only thing the raters can do is rate it as both Errol and Fulton were at their best, which is what they have done placing TC at one.

            Comment

            • Slip jab
              Undisputed Champion
              Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
              • Feb 2021
              • 1171
              • 444
              • 415
              • 0

              #26
              I like that Lopez is in of the strength of big wins at 35 and 40. He does have a loss.
              I strongly disagree that Davis is top10.. he’s never established himself as the top guy in every division he’s operated at.. he seems to be in off a his commercial appeal. Davis vs Joe Shmoe next in a $100 ppv. Davis wins and shoots up yo top5 because we’re not voting on the strength of his opposition but his commercial appeal. Get off Al’s lap bscene lol I’m playing guys but I feel my criticism keeps y’all honest. Put me on the voting panel fam lol
              Last edited by Slip jab; 08-07-2023, 09:42 PM.

              Comment

              • Dean_Razorback
                God of Thunder and R n' R
                Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                • Jan 2013
                • 16556
                • 1,022
                • 395
                • 98,048

                #27
                Originally posted by ShoulderRoll

                Nonito just lost again. He’s old and past it.

                Spence broke Ugas’ face after that deadly car crash.
                nonito was crawford's age when he lost the first fight with inoue and in his next fight became a world champion lol spence had to drop out of the fight wiht manny because he had a detached retina, dude is a mess

                Comment

                • The D3vil
                  WBA/WBC/WBO/IBF/Lineal
                  Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                  • Mar 2016
                  • 6108
                  • 1,535
                  • 1,353
                  • 56,286

                  #28
                  Originally posted by Roadblock

                  Ok that's fair enough, but lets play devils advocate where do you stand if Errol was really messed up, what does it mean then?
                  Messed up by what?

                  What could've messed him up between the time he broke Ugas' face and losing to Crawford?

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  TOP