Is Inoue Greater Than Lomachenko

[HeadShots]

That's a very hot take. Borderline ridiculous. Naravez was undisputed and beat 5 straight undefeated fighters like Josh Taylor?

you are the one with the ridiculous mental gymnastics.



How many divisions did Josh Taylor win titles in? How many defences?


Narvaez 2 divisions. 8 defences and 13 defences each.

[MikeyMike100]

you are the one with the ridiculous mental gymnastics.



How many divisions did Josh Taylor win titles in? How many defences?


Narvaez 2 divisions. 8 defences and 13 defences each.

Josh Taylor was undisputed and beat 5 straight undefeated fighters. It's like saying that Leo Santa Cruz is better than Errol Spence because he won at more weight classes

[HeadShots]

Josh Taylor was undisputed and beat 5 straight undefeated fighters. It's like saying that Leo Santa Cruz is better than Errol Spence because he won at more weight classes

how many of them are going in the HOF? so undefeated bums count as what historically?


it's what makes Donaire better than Errol Spence.

[F l i c k e r]

As a pro? Sure.

the only thing Lomachenko has going for him truly is an extensive amateur career. Take that away and he won a title in 3 fights but proceed to take Ls vs the elites of his generation.

Whereas Inoue isn’t just beating the elites but destroying them.

[Mike_b]

Let's see them play that at 126 then we could talk about it!

[satiev1]

Inoue is lucky to be around garbage opposition. If loma was 122 lbs he'd wipe the floor with inoue. Loma's frame should never have gotten above 130 lbs. He's a tiny tiny 135 lber.

[satiev1]

As a pro? Sure.

the only thing Lomachenko has going for him truly is an extensive amateur career. Take that away and he won a title in 3 fights but proceed to take Ls vs the elites of his generation.

Whereas Inoue isn’t just beating the elites but destroying them.

Inoue isn't beating any elites. Walters who loma destroyed wiped the floor with inoue's best win donaire.

[MikeyMike100]

how many of them are going in the HOF? so undefeated bums count as what historically?


it's what makes Donaire better than Errol Spence.

Ridiculous to call Taylors opposition bums

[satiev1]

Loma lost to Salido, Teo and Haney. Salido and Teo are legit journeyman historically.


even if you were to argue otherwise, they were razor thin fights. Inoue never had such fights.

Inoue never faced anyone 3 weight classes up remotely close to the skill level of teo or haney. Fulton is 3 levels below each of those guys. His best win against donaire got koed cold by walters who loma had a sparring session with.

[Sharpshootah]

No. Loma's amateur rec trumps anything Inoue has done. Inoue is top 5 though, good time to be a fight fan