How do you Rate the Jr Welterweights

[Run]

I think Judah is a very overrated fighter. One of the most overrated in boxing.

That is ridiculous.

How does beating Pineda, Spinks, Ward, Corley, Weis, Witter, Bergman make you overrated.

That is a bull**** statement with absolutely no logic behind it.

You can not say the welterweight champion of the world is overrated: the guy he beat to get that title was.
He is more underrated than overrated.



Never pay again for live sex! | Hot girls doing naughty stuff for free! | Chat for free!

[The Troll]

Jan Bergman is not a world class fighter yet he managed to knock down Judah. Judah also only "beat"(using the word "beat" very *******ly) chop chop corley by a split descision, split descisions are often hardly victories. That fight really could have gone either way. And Judah's victory against Weis is also not very impressive Weis was old when he fought Judah. Judah beat Weis, big deal, a year after Judah beat Weis so did a club fighter with a record of 18-6. Judah is overrated it is true, it can not be denied.
He has two quality wins and that is all, his TKO of Spinks and his UD of ward.

[Moonra69]

tszyu
mayweather
cotto
gatti
harris

[ZaneTeal]

As a weight class, I'd rate it a helluva lot higher than last year, because these guys are getting off their asses & fighting each other. It's the deepest division in boxing, and these fights should have happened already.

Individually:

1. Tszyu
2. Mayweather
3. Gatti
4. Harris
5. Hatton
6. Cotto
7. Mitchell
8. Corley
9. Witter
10. Augustus

[ZaneTeal]

I'll tell you right now.... Emmanuel Augustus would beat anyone below Mayweather. But he doesn't fight enough, and he has a lot of losses, albeit bull**** losses.

[The Troll]

Gatti would get to Mitchell's fragile chin eventually at some point in the fight and that would be it. So yes, I do indeed consider Gatti a better fighter than Mitchell. (in response to somebodies question)

[dcgun]

1. Tszyu
2. Mayweather
3. Gatti
4. Cotto
5. Hatton

[masterdirector]

1. Mayweather
2. Tszyu
3. Harris
4. Witter

Judah beats them all, except probably Mayweather would win a close chessmatch decision.

[Alpha Male]

1. Tsyzu
2. Mayweather
3. Harris
4. Gatti
5. Bruseles

Judah loses to Tszyu and Mayweather. His KO of Spinks doesn't impress me. He should not have been in that fight in the first place. If, he wasn't so careless and ****y in their first meeting the second would've never happened.

[The Troll]

Well it seems to be the UD here that Mayweather and Tzyu are the top II Jr. Welterweights. They are both most likely to win their upcoming bouts. I think its clear that the fight to see is between Tzyu and Mayweather. I would go with Mayweather in that fight. He has youth, handspeed, strongess, on his side.