Better resume: Casamayor or Tarver?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • oldgringo
    Ellis
    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
    • Jul 2004
    • 12747
    • 968
    • 453
    • 30,064

    #21
    Originally posted by IMDAZED
    He beat Castillo???
    Immediately after I watched the fight the first time around I thought Joel edged JLC by a point or two. It has been a long time since I've seen it though. I'd like to watch it again.

    Comment

    • oldgringo
      Ellis
      Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
      • Jul 2004
      • 12747
      • 968
      • 453
      • 30,064

      #22
      Originally posted by The_Executioner
      Floyd would spank Casamayor...just my opinion...


      I'd give the better resume to Casamayor...although I don't think either resume is that special...
      It would have been a good fight. Casamayor was pretty crafty in there and wasn't mentally weak. I think the fact that he was a southpaw and had above average hitting power/hand speed would have troubled Floyd for the majority of the fight.

      Comment

      • Doctor_Tenma
        Monster
        Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
        • Apr 2009
        • 33313
        • 1,327
        • 1,249
        • 58,127

        #23
        Originally posted by oldgringo
        It would have been a good fight. Casamayor was pretty crafty in there and wasn't mentally weak. I think the fact that he was a southpaw and had above average hitting power/hand speed would have troubled Floyd for the majority of the fight.
        Casamayor would have gave Mayweather serious problems. I mean, Hatton wasn't a bad clincher but Joel would land his 1-2 before he tied you up.
        Last edited by Doctor_Tenma; 10-01-2009, 09:27 AM.

        Comment

        • IMDAZED
          Fair but Firm
          Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
          • May 2006
          • 42644
          • 1,134
          • 1,770
          • 67,152

          #24
          Originally posted by oldgringo
          It would have been a good fight. Casamayor was pretty crafty in there and wasn't mentally weak. I think the fact that he was a southpaw and had above average hitting power/hand speed would have troubled Floyd for the majority of the fight.
          I agree. I always thought it would have been a very intriguing matchup but it never happened .

          Comment

          • Doctor_Tenma
            Monster
            Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
            • Apr 2009
            • 33313
            • 1,327
            • 1,249
            • 58,127

            #25
            Originally posted by IMDAZED
            He beat Castillo???
            I scored it, 7 rounds to 5, Casamayor.

            Comment

            • IMDAZED
              Fair but Firm
              Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
              • May 2006
              • 42644
              • 1,134
              • 1,770
              • 67,152

              #26
              Originally posted by Dominicano Soy!
              I scored it, 7 rounds to 5, Casamayor.
              I thought Castillo won but it was close as heck. Was just wondering when they overturned the decision - wasn't like it was a robbery although I think I remember the scorecards being strange in that one.

              Comment

              • Doctor_Tenma
                Monster
                Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                • Apr 2009
                • 33313
                • 1,327
                • 1,249
                • 58,127

                #27
                Originally posted by IMDAZED
                I thought Castillo won but it was close as heck. Was just wondering when they overturned the decision - wasn't like it was a robbery although I think I remember the scorecards being strange in that one.
                While I had it as a close but clear victory for Joel Casamayor, we should have atleast gotten a rematch. Joel didn't get his rightfully deserved rematchs against both Freitas and JLC, wonder what went wrong.

                Comment

                • IMDAZED
                  Fair but Firm
                  Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                  • May 2006
                  • 42644
                  • 1,134
                  • 1,770
                  • 67,152

                  #28
                  Originally posted by Dominicano Soy!
                  While I had it as a close but clear victory for Joel Casamayor, we should have atleast gotten a rematch. Joel didn't get his rightfully deserved rematchs against both Freitas and JLC, wonder what went wrong.
                  I definitely thought he beat Freitas. You know Popo didn't want to see him again. And I really thought Floyd should've went after Joel once it became apparent Freitas wasn't interested but he never showed an inclination to do so.

                  Comment

                  • Doctor_Tenma
                    Monster
                    Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                    • Apr 2009
                    • 33313
                    • 1,327
                    • 1,249
                    • 58,127

                    #29
                    Originally posted by IMDAZED
                    I definitely thought he beat Freitas. You know Popo didn't want to see him again. And I really thought Floyd should've went after Joel once it became apparent Freitas wasn't interested but he never showed an inclination to do so.
                    That is the one fight I would have LOVED to see, I can understand why Hatton/ Cotto/ Tszyu didn't happen at Jr WW but there was no reason for Mayweather vs. Casamayor not going down.

                    Comment

                    • Doctor_Tenma
                      Monster
                      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
                      • Apr 2009
                      • 33313
                      • 1,327
                      • 1,249
                      • 58,127

                      #30
                      As for Freitas,

                      That was a BULL**** point deduction/ K.D...even with that, Casamayor should have still won.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP