Better resume: Casamayor or Tarver?

[eazy_mas]

Casamayor was in the golden era of the SFW and LW.

In that fighters like Frietas, Castillo, Corrales and Mayweather where there.

Mayweather moved toward the upper weight class but still the competiton was pretty good.

Also he fought some young lads and once called Mr Zero for beating alot of undeafted fighter.

So pretty much I going with Casamayor

[Fox McCloud]

Casa didn't duck. He was ducked.

See keV, we agree-
Again!

Haha, I'm sure Casamayor was just aching to lose his 0 to the better boxer in Mayweather.

Or, as usually is the case, both people thought they were worth more money than they were, so they couldn't agree on a purse split.

Come on, you know how this works...

[Blue Heffner]

Cassamayor and he will return continuing to fight top fighter. I think he's moving up to junior welter.

[IMDAZED]

Haha, I'm sure Casamayor was just aching to lose his 0 to the better boxer in Mayweather.

Or, as usually is the case, both people thought they were worth more money than they were, so they couldn't agree on a purse split.

Come on, you know how this works...

Casamayor was very keen of fighting Mayweather. It was Freitas who didn't want that problem.

[street bully]

Casamayor. He is a first ballot HOFer IMO, and he beat Corrales, Castillo, and Frietas too.

[#1Assassin]

Casamayor. He is a first ballot HOFer IMO, and he beat Corrales, Castillo, and Frietas too.

i agree with this. casamayor is one of the most underrated and underappreciated fighters of all times. one of the very best p4p fighters of his era. tarver has some good wins but its not really comparable to casamayor.

[The Underboss]

Tarver.....

[-EX-]

Casamayor was very keen of fighting Mayweather. It was Freitas who didn't want that problem.

Floyd would spank Casamayor...just my opinion...


I'd give the better resume to Casamayor...although I don't think either resume is that special...

[IMDAZED]

Casamayor. He is a first ballot HOFer IMO, and he beat Corrales, Castillo, and Frietas too.

He beat Castillo???

[Doctor_Tenma]

i agree with this. casamayor is one of the most underrated and underappreciated fighters of all times. one of the very best p4p fighters of his era. tarver has some good wins but its not really comparable to casamayor.

What would have been of Casamayor, had he gotten the W against Acelino, JLC and Corrales rematch (As he should have), I only wonder.