Who has fought better opposition, Floyd or Calzaghe?

[Shadows]

They're fairly even, but I give Floyd the edge for what he did early in his career.

[Shadows]

2 of my least favorite boxers in the sport. Both fighters greatness is highly overrated, but at least calzaghe fought everybody in his division & beat all comers. When was the last time mr.counterfeit cash beat the 1# guy in his division?

130 lbs? corrales?

Castillo at 135.

[BEEHOP]

Floyd and it's not even close.

[Pullcounter]

floyd's is better. but i voted calz just to piss off floyd stans.

[Kevin Jesus]

2 of my least favorite boxers in the sport. Both fighters greatness is highly overrated, but at least calzaghe fought everybody in his division & beat all comers. When was the last time mr.counterfeit cash beat the 1# guy in his division?

130 lbs? corrales?

Corrales, Castillo, Baldomir, and De La Hoya were all ranked number 1 in their division by The Ring when Floyd fought them.

[Steak]

not true, Baldomir was rated in the champion status, which is different from #1, simply because he was not rated highly at all before fighting Judah. I mean, Gatti was favoured to beat him.

DLH was not #1 in the division at the time, he was rated from 3-5.

anyways, Floyd.

[Kevin Jesus]

not true, Baldomir was rated in the champion status, which is different from #1, simply because he was not rated highly at all before fighting Judah. I mean, Gatti was favoured to beat him.

DLH was not #1 in the division at the time, he was rated from 3-5.

anyways, Floyd.

Baldomir was the lineal champion at WW cause he beat Judah who was the Lineal champion.



I'm gonna look in to De La Hoya right now.

[MANGLER]

Baldomir was the lineal champion at WW cause he beat Judah who was the Lineal champion.



I'm gonna look in to De La Hoya right now.

Karmazin, Ouma, and Spinks were ranked above him.

[Kevin Jesus]

The Ring WW Champions

Welterweight
Number Champion Reign
1 Flag of Canada Jimmy McLarnin 1933 -
2 Flag of the United States Barney Ross 1937 - May 31, 1938
3 Flag of the United States Henry Armstrong May 31, 1938 - October 4, 1940
4 Flag of the United States Fritzie Zivic October 4, 1940 -
5 Flag of the United States Freddie Cochrane July 29, 1941 - February 1, 1946
6 Flag of the United States Marty Servo February 1, 1946 - September 1946 (Vacated)
7 Flag of the United States Sugar Ray Robinson December 20, 1946 -
8 Flag of Cuba Kid Gavilan (beat Billy Graham) August 29, 1951 - October 20, 1954
9 Flag of the United States Johnny Saxton October 20, 1954 - April 1, 1955
10 Flag of the United States Tony DeMarco April 1, 1955 - June 10, 1955
11 Flag of the United States Carmen Basilio June 10, 1955 - March 14, 1956
12 Flag of the United States Johnny Saxton March 14, 1956 - September 12, 1956
13 Flag of the United States Carmen Basilio September 12, 1956 - 1957 (Vacated)
14 Flag of the United States Don Jordan 1959 -
15 Flag of the United States ****** Islands Emile Griffith April 1, 1961 - September 30, 1961
16 Flag of Cuba Benny Paret September 30, 1961 - March 24, 1962
17 Flag of the United States ****** Islands Emile Griffith March 24, 1962 - March 21, 1963
18 Flag of Cuba Luis Manuel Rodriguez March 21, 1963 - June 8, 1963
19 Flag of the United States ****** Islands Emile Griffith June 8, 1963 - April 1966 (Vacated}
20 Flag of the United States Curtis Cokes 1967 - April 18, 1969
21 Flag of Cuba Jose Napoles April 18, 1969 - December 3, 1970
22 Flag of the United States Billy Backus December 3, 1970 - June 4, 1971
23 Flag of Cuba Jose Napoles June 4, 1971 - December 6, 1975
24 Flag of the United Kingdom John Stracey December 6, 1975 - June 22, 1976
25 Flag of Mexico Carlos Palomino June 22, 1976 - January 14, 1979
26 Flag of Puerto Rico Wilfred Benitez January 14, 1979 - November 30, 1979
27 Flag of the United States Sugar Ray Leonard November 30, 1979 - June 20, 1980
28 Flag of Panama Roberto Duran June 20, 1980 - November 25, 1980
29 Flag of the United States Sugar Ray Leonard November 25, 1980 - November 9, 1982 (Retired)
30 Flag of the United States Donald Curry (defeated Milton McCrory) December 6, 1985 - September 27, 1986
31 Flag of the United Kingdom Lloyd Honeyghan September 27, 1986 - October 27, 1987
32 Flag of Mexico Jorge Vaca October 27, 1987 - March 29, 1988
33 Flag of the United Kingdom Lloyd Honeyghan March 29, 1988 - February 4, 1989
34 Flag of the United States Marlon Starling February 4, 1989 - March 2, 1989 (Ring ceased publication for 7 months)
35 Flag of the United States Vernon Forrest (beat Shane Mosley) January 26, 2002 - January 25, 2003
36 Flag of Nicaragua Ricardo Mayorga January 25, 2003 - December 13, 2003
37 Flag of the United States Cory Spinks December 13, 2003 - February 5, 2005
38 Flag of the United States Zab Judah February 5, 2005 - January 7, 2006
39 Flag of Argentina Carlos Manuel Baldomir January 7, 2006 - November 4 , 2006
40 Flag of the United States Floyd Mayweather Jr. November 4 , 2006 - June 29, 2008 (Retired)

[-EX-]

If Floyd stayed at one weight for most of his career it could be close but he didn't...him jumping up in weight capturing titles triumphs Calzaghe...

This question shouldn't even be asked...