Who has fought better opposition, Floyd or Calzaghe?

[shonuff488]

Joe's best win is a controversial decision over Bernard Hopkins. It's also a win that he did not set the record straight in. Floyd had controversial decision over Castillo. He immediately had a rematch to prove who was better.

You guys over rate Kessler too much. I think he is a good boxer, but what has he done besides lose to Joe.

Floyd=Castillo, Hatton, De la Hoya, Marquez, Corrales, Judah, Hernandez, Gatti,

Joe=Lacy, Kessler, Eubank, Hopkins(43), Jones(39)

Floyd's resume is already better than Joe's and he is still fighting. Which means he has time to add a Pac, Cotto, or Mosley to his resume.

[IMDAZED]

It was sarcasm. Point being Corrales never belonged amoung the top 5 fighters in the world at any point in his career.

Maybe, maybe not. That's debatable, especially since he has a pretty good resume. Kessler on the other hand...

Anyway, I think Floyd had the better resume.

[Chups]

About the same.

[Kevin Jesus]

That's odd, Mayweather has been winning Boxingscene polls lately.

In the beggining of the year Floyd would have lost this poll 500 to 25.

I guess his new respectful character won him some more fans.

[S.G.]

That's odd, Mayweather has been winning Boxingscene polls lately.

In the beggining of the year Floyd would have lost this poll 500 to 25.

I guess his new respectful character won him some more fans.

to be fair if there's anyone who has a claim to getting more **** than mayweather on nsb it's calzaghe lol

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Maybe, maybe not. That's debatable, especially since he has a pretty good resume. Kessler on the other hand...

Anyway, I think Floyd had the better resume.

At the time he fought Mayweather, his resume wasnt that much better than Kessler's (if at all).

[IMDAZED]

At the time he fought Mayweather, his resume wasnt that much better than Kessler's (if at all).

I disagree. So did the majority but whatever. He was pound for pound at the time.

[Spacey1991]

Mr boat buyer catches **** for not fightin the toughest comp at WW, but his overall resume is damn good. Better than Joe C's 4 sho.

Yup, WW is the only wait were you can say he could/should have done more.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Yup, WW is the only wait were you can say he could/should have done more.

What about 140?

[Dirk Diggler UK]

I disagree. So did the majority but whatever. He was pound for pound at the time.

Corrales best win was?