Would you all agree that floyd mayweather jr. is the MOST GIFTED(wins) FIGHTER OF ALL TIME?

[Ganondorf]

Castillo I
Maidana I
Dela hoya
There could be more but the 3 fights was one of the most controversial win in boxing history.

I don't know if there's anyone in the past who has more gift wins than mayweather but it's hard to surpass mayweather gift wins.

It’s like y’all don’t even try anymore!

[4truth]

He lost the first Castillo fight.

Oscar lost his fight by trying to do too much in the second half of the fight. It was close but imo Oscar gave it away.

I was surprised that Maidana did as well as he did, considering he arguably couldn't win a single round vs Devon Alexander but I didn't have him winning.

[War Room]

Castillo I
Maidana I
Dela hoya
There could be more but the 3 fights was one of the most controversial win in boxing history.

I don't know if there's anyone in the past who has more gift wins than mayweather but it's hard to surpass mayweather gift wins.

Castillo was a 1 round fight for me that couldn't not have gone either way.

Maidana and Oscar were clear cut wins. Mayweather haters are like everywhere decades later lmao. They're so rattled.

I scored the number of clean punches in the fight between Mayweather and De La Hoya. Excluding any missed shots, my score was:

Round 1: Oscar-13 Floyd-8 (10-9)
Round 2: Oscar-8 Floyd-3 (10-9)
Round 3: Oscar-10 Floyd-5 (10-9)
Round 4: Oscar-18 Floyd-6 (10-9)
Round 5: Oscar-13 Floyd-13 (10-10 or 9-9)
Round 6: Oscar-13 Floyd-5 (10-9)
Round 7: Oscar-14 Floyd-8 (10-9)
Round 8: Oscar-11 Floyd-5 (10-9)
Round 9: Oscar-7 Floyd-6 (10-9)
Round10: Oscar-12 Floyd-9 (10-9)
Round11: Oscar-8 Floyd-15 (9-10)
Round12: Oscar-24 Floyd-13 (10-9)

Is there an actual CompuBox for that fight though? My scorecard looks quite flawed despite that I checked carefully. If I were scoring rounds while ignoring the punching count, the rounds that favor Floyd would probably be 1,5,9,10 and 11.

1. This isn't the amateurs.
2. Your punch count is off.
3. Not all punches are counted equally.
4. Floyd clearly won round 1 (just rewatched it).
5. Floyd won that fight 116-112.
6. Compubox has a huge margin of error.

[djtmal]

Floyds pops thought Oscar beat him.

You could make a case for Castillo.

[EmpiresBoxing]

Can we all agree the dude in your pic was on steroids and threw more shots with his head than his fists?

I love Evander but Jesus Christ. Don’t join yesterday, use a pic of EVANDER HOLYFIELD , and come talking shlt about Floyd, please and thank you!

Evander probably was on PEDS but mayweather PEDS are far superior and now almost every top fighters are on PEDS specially spence, crawford, davis etc. the only clean fighter today is haney and he also don't cherry pick his opponent like mayweather.

[The D3vil]

Nah.

You can argue Oscar & Castillo, but he won those other ones.

But Oscar arguably robbed Ike Quartey & Pernell Whittaker

Chavez robbed Whittaker & had Richard Steele rob Meldrick Taylor.

Canelo arguably robbed Lara, Trout, and GGG twice & even got one bull**** card against Mayweather.

The A-side guys always get the benefit of the doubt

[gauze]

I scored the number of clean punches in the fight between Mayweather and De La Hoya. Excluding any missed shots, my score was:

Round 1: Oscar-13 Floyd-8 (10-9)
Round 2: Oscar-8 Floyd-3 (10-9)
Round 3: Oscar-10 Floyd-5 (10-9)
Round 4: Oscar-18 Floyd-6 (10-9)
Round 5: Oscar-13 Floyd-13 (10-10 or 9-9)
Round 6: Oscar-13 Floyd-5 (10-9)
Round 7: Oscar-14 Floyd-8 (10-9)
Round 8: Oscar-11 Floyd-5 (10-9)
Round 9: Oscar-7 Floyd-6 (10-9)
Round10: Oscar-12 Floyd-9 (10-9)
Round11: Oscar-8 Floyd-15 (9-10)
Round12: Oscar-24 Floyd-13 (10-9)

Is there an actual CompuBox for that fight though? My scorecard looks quite flawed despite that I checked carefully. If I were scoring rounds while ignoring the punching count, the rounds that favor Floyd would probably be 1,5,9,10 and 11.

you're talking about scoring a round 9-9 which tells me you are a complete and utter moron who knows nothing about scoring fights. stop posting.

[Malvado]

you're talking about scoring a round 9-9 which tells me you are a complete and utter moron who knows nothing about scoring fights. stop posting.

Sure buddy, I stop posting because you said so. I swear inbred kunts like you tend to deter the casual fanbase from watching boxing. If you're going to nitpick every mistake, at least be reasonable and just state why I was wrong, no need to berate me.

[STREET CLEANER]

Mayweather haters keeping him current.

In the ODLH fight I betted Floyd to win. Some paid me even without finishing the fight. Once it got boring you knew Floyd was winning.

[gauze]

Sure buddy, I stop posting because you said so. I swear inbred kunts like you tend to deter the casual fanbase from watching boxing. If you're going to nitpick every mistake, at least be reasonable and just state why I was wrong, no need to berate me.

10 point must system. you only score a round 9-9 if the fighter that won the round had a point deducted by the referee for a foul.