What is the better accomplishment? Pacquiao win vs Oscar or FMJ win vs Marquez?

[goldenglove2]

The answer should be obvious: PBF's win over JMM. At least JMM fought and had a chance. DLH was too dehydrated and Manny weighed more than him. Even the slimy Freddie Roach laughed and giggled about seeing fresh iv marks on DLH on fight night. He was disabled.

Floyd giggled when he weighed in at 146....PUH LEASE........

Floyd fought an older fighter than Dela who had never even see a weight class above 135.......Dela was once a title holder at 147.....

[AntDawg]

Pacquiao win over Oscar of course. Almost no one seen that coming and just about everyone knew Mayweather would beat Marquez.

[Ravishing]

Funny because even Marquez would have beaten that version of Oscar. Doesn't take a WW to beat that Oscar, a good SFW in Soto would have done the job. Mayweather's win over Marquez ofcourse.

I don't think so...

Marquez clearly was not suited for Welterweight. Pacquiao was able to carry up his ability in the ring from the lighter weights as where Marquez had trouble even at Lightweight.

Its a win / win anyway you look at it for Pacquiao. The smaller guy beating the bigger guy is always going to be favored.

[Doctor_Tenma]

I don't think so...

Marquez clearly was not suited for Welterweight. Pacquiao was able to carry up his ability in the ring from the lighter weights as where Marquez had trouble even at Lightweight.

Its a win / win anyway you look at it for Pacquiao. The smaller guy beating the bigger guy is always going to be favored.

Pacquiao wasn't the smaller man that night.

[hammerhiem]

Neither are an "accomplishment" worth the name, but at least Pac went up to beat Oscar.

they are both so bad an accomplishemnt that i rate Calzaghe beating RJJ higher than either.

[Pullcounter]

c'mon man.... pac jumped 2 weight divisions to fight dlh (albeit a drained dlh)....

but floyd stacked the deck against a LW...

[-GR -]

Floyd giggled when he weighed in at 146....PUH LEASE........

Floyd fought an older fighter than Dela who had never even see a weight class above 135.......Dela was once a title holder at 147.....

Once years ago. Doesn't change the fact his body rejected the re-hydration and he was ****ed. He could have died that night. JMM was live but fought a better fighter.

JMM would have beat DLH that night. He was a standing target

[madsweeney]

Delahoya was a weight drained zombie that`s why Pacquiao and Roach cherry picked him and made him come down in wait.It was to drain him of his energy so everybody could say pacquiao is god.

And Floyd cherry picked a freaking lightweight (just like DLH thought he was) that he had EVERY physical advantage on. Difference was DLH killed himself weeks before the fight and couldn't do **** to Pac.

[madsweeney]

Once years ago. Doesn't change the fact his body rejected the re-hydration and he was ****ed. He could have died that night. JMM was live but fought a better fighter.

JMM would have beat DLH that night. He was a standing target

LOL dude hardly seemed dehydrated. he had a good sweat from the ring entrance till he quit on his stool. He lost too much body weight from his crazy dieting. He was in the 140's weeks before the damn match, that's not dehydration buddy.

[madsweeney]

Pacquiao wasn't the smaller man that night.

He still was smaller in every way except weight.