Comments Thread For: Top Six Unchanged, Haney Debuts: BoxingScene Competition Index October Update

[tkoboxingscene]

How clenelo, Taylor, and nomachenko make it I to any too list this year shows how clownish and bias these platforms are.

[ShoulderRoll]

...






so..... the guy who is probably the best fighter in the world, does not even make the top 10 ?

you cannot box-by-numbers, this is not a maths game

mathematical scoring systems simply do not work, how can anyone not be aware of that ???

a board room discussion > vote > decision.... is far more accurate, and the only method that could work






...

The list ranks who is facing the toughest opposition.

It's easy to look like the best fighter in the world against easy opponents.

[aboutfkntime]

The list ranks who is facing the toughest opposition.

It's easy to look like the best fighter in the world against easy opponents.

It's not easy to look like the best ranking authority in the world when you exclude the best fighter from your P4P list because maths told you to






...

[ShoulderRoll]

It's not easy to look like the best ranking authority in the world when you exclude the best fighter from your P4P list because maths told you to






...

It's not a P4P list. It's a Competition Index.

If a guy isn't fighting tough opposition then the numbers are going to reflect that. The numbers don't care about "eye test" or people's feelings.

[aboutfkntime]

It's not a P4P list. It's a Competition Index.

If a guy isn't fighting tough opposition then the numbers are going to reflect that. The numbers don't care about "eye test" or people's feelings.

call it whatever you want.....


it is going to look pretty ****** if Crawford beats Spence.... which is highly likely


what will they do.... add him back on the list in the number 1 spot ?


when you take a irrational position, and are immediately forced to crawl up your own ass and reverse that irrational decision.... it means you had no idea what you were doing, because your system is highly flawed






...