Who is the BEST Welterweight in the World?

[El Chicano]

Rank Them.

Shane Mosley

Miguel Cotto

Floyd Mayweather

[Pounding]

Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley
Floyd Mayweather

[STILL_DETOX]

Pbf>>>mc>>>ssm

[jazluvr]

Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley
Floyd Mayweather

That's the way i see it.

[Jone2ts]

Mayweather
Mosley
are the best...Pac & Cotto 2nd tier.

[SOY-COMO-SOY]

Kinda difficult to answer.......................

cotto beat mosley (twice)
cotto quit to marg
then mosley dominated marg


floyd wont fight a true WW



I will have to say cotto, cuz marg vs. mosley wasnt the usual marg. had nothing to do w/ plaster, IMHO marg looked drugged or mest up before the first round of the mosley fight.

[Mr. Philadel]

Mosley and Cotto are debatable (it depends on who you ask).....but
Mayweather?......what TOP WW has he beat?!? or fought?!?!?......Cotto? NO....Marg?.....NO.....Clottey?.....NO.....Mosley? NO......he has to fight a WW to be ranked!!.....not just weigh-in as one!!

[Jim Jeffries]

Mayweather
Mosley
are the best...Pac & Cotto 2nd tier.

Now I know you're just a troll. How does 2nd tier (Cotto) beat the best (Mosley?)

[El Angel]

Cotto and Mosley are pretty close. Cotto beat Mosley head to head, but Mosley beat Marg who beat Cotto. They're 1A and 1B IMO. Mayweather is below them. He has a great overall resume, just not as good a WW resume as Cotto and Mosley right now.

[Guest]

Kinda difficult to answer.......................

cotto beat mosley (twice)
cotto quit to marg
then mosley dominated marg


floyd wont fight a true WW



I will have to say cotto, cuz marg vs. mosley wasnt the usual marg. had nothing to do w/ plaster, IMHO marg looked drugged or mest up before the first round of the mosley fight.

Marg lost a ton of weight after coming in to camp way heavy so that could be part of why he looked as he did.
They said he was over 180 coming into camp, and lost a lot of weight quickly.
That's probably why you saw him weaker than usual that night (plus I am sure the other goings on had some effect)

And I agree, if you evaluate Mayweather, you do it on if's.
Of course I think he can beat Cotto and Mosley, it's just a question of if he fights them.