Floyd cannot be p4p no.1. He's not even top of his division

[VipersThunder]

Case in point. Floyd is not the top welterweight in the world. Hence he cannot be p4p no.1.

That is all.

Good point and true.

[WhoreUs]

he just beat the p4p #2 fighter in the world, tell me whos ranked higher p4p marquez or mosley

so if kelly pavlik beats miguel cotto at 160 does that make him #2 p4p?

[Chunk..]

What about punching power?

It's more based on resumees. Otherwise young pup's like Direll and Ward should be on the p4p list today and you would have to place Sven Ottke higher on the ATG list and . That guy was skilled.

There's a world of difference between those guys you mentioned and a Mayweather, and if you base it on resumes then you'd still have to put Mayweather up there.

He ain't P4P#1, i ain't saying that but Mayweather purely just fighting welterweights isn't the only way he'll get top spot again.

IF he fights Paquiao, another smaller guy at 147 - Floyd's top dog again, guaranteed.

[WhoreUs]

The P4P list is based on skills, at least i think it is?

then why isn't calderon at the top of the list?

resume plays a big part in it as well.

[Stoppage]

boxrec.com rates him as the best welterweight in the world. That's a joke. He put on a good performance last night but there's a different between a lightweight and a welterweight.

[razor.thin]

so if kelly pavlik beats miguel cotto at 160 does that make him #2 p4p?

no because fight night weight marquez and floyd are same.

[nachorjj]

he is the P4P, is the best WW the only one who can give turbels to floyd is Mosley. Cotto Pacquiao Margarito Marquez Berto

[BattlingNelson]

There's a world of difference between those guys you mentioned and a Mayweather, and if you base it on resumes then you'd still have to put Mayweather up there.

He ain't P4P#1, i ain't saying that but Mayweather purely just fighting welterweights isn't the only way he'll get top spot again.

IF he fights Paquiao, another smaller guy at 147 - Floyd's top dog again, guaranteed.

Maybe, but you can then take a great technician straight out of the olympics and then, based on your criterias, rank him high on the p4p list. Sorry, but that just doesn't add up. You have to include resumées.

[BattlingNelson]

boxrec.com rates him as the best welterweight in the world. That's a joke. He put on a good performance last night but there's a different between a lightweight and a welterweight.

Boxrecs rankings are computerized and is not to be taken too serious.

[Chunk..]

Mr boat buyer ain't prove **** beatin a LW at WW. He can be the top dog again if he beats SSM and the Pac-Cotto winner.

Pacquiao's a top Welterweight?