Is Inoue The Number 1 P4P In The World?

[MikeyMike100]

3 division champ with 3 titles currently. If hes not number 1 then who is and why?

[tonysoprano]

P4P hardest puncher for sure. He's ruining guys in 3 different divisions. Nobody else doing that.

[MikeyMike100]

an

P4P hardest puncher for sure. He's ruining guys in 3 different divisions. Nobody else doing that.

Deontay Wilder is definitely the biggest puncher P4P not just today but in boxing history.

[1lparm]

an

Deontay Wilder is definitely the biggest puncher P4P not just today but in boxing history.

Sadly I have to agree with this even though I’m not a big fan. Wilder would possibly kill Inoue in a fight so hard to dispute he hits harder than him.

[-Kev-]

He just beat a 40 year old Donaire.

He might be P4P #1-3 but please guys, not due to KO’ing a 40 year old, past prime Donaire. Anything else other than his latest win.

He is up there as 1 of the best 6 fighters in boxing: Usyk, Fury, Canelo, Spence, Inoue, Lomachenko. In no particular order. I think those are the best P4P fighters right now.

If Bivol can beat Beterbiev, he deserves to be called top 5 P4P as well.

I’m flexible with the P4P list. I don’t believe in just dropping and raising fighters for no matter who they lost to or who they beat. I think that’s really unfair that some guy KO’s a 40 year old, moves up in the list, but some other fighter loses to a young, prime, undefeated fighter and just gets dropped and forgotten (Lomachenko-Lopez). It’s nonsense imo. Then P4P fighters should just duck the best, prime fighters and go on a Senior tour just beating up on old or past prime fighters and keep moving up in the P4P ranks.

[ShoulderRoll]

No.

Nonito is his best win and he's almost 40.

Usyk went up in weight and schooled a prime Anthony Joshua.

[MikeyMike100]

He just beat a 40 year old Donaire.

He might be P4P #1-3 but please guys, not due to KO’ing a 40 year old, past prime Donaire. Anything else other than his latest win.

He is up there as 1 of the best 6 fighters in boxing: Usyk, Fury, Canelo, Spence, Inoue, Lomachenko. In no particular order. I think those are the best P4P fighters right now.

If Bivol can beat Beterbiev, he deserves to be called top 5 P4P as well.

I’m flexible with the P4P list. I don’t believe in just dropping and raising fighters for no matter who they lost to or who they beat. I think that’s really unfair that some guy KO’s a 40 year old, moves up in the list, but some other fighter loses to a young, prime, undefeated fighter and just gets dropped and forgotten (Lomachenko-Lopez). It’s nonsense imo. Then P4P fighters should just duck the best, prime fighters and go on a Senior tour just beating up on old or past prime fighters and keep moving up in the P4P ranks.

I agree with a lot of this. If Crawford and Spence fight the winner will probably be considered the best in the world.

[JOITATS]

inoue p4p #1
usyk #2

inoue has obliterated everyone hes fought. no one has ever done that to donaire. oubaali and gaballo are solid kos.

usyk has not dominated everyone.
anthony joshua was also beat by a much smaller ruiz, who is avg

donaire is a beast, and the first time he fought inoue was the same age as ggg and porter.

canelo struggled with ggg, lara.. lost to mayweather, bivol

crawfords best win is porter and postol, who has basically lost to every top guy

[Mammoth]

These lists are subjective but he very well could be. Nobody in another division isn't dealing with anything like him.

[Rockybigblower]

He just beat a 40 year old Donaire.

He might be P4P #1-3 but please guys, not due to KO’ing a 40 year old, past prime Donaire. Anything else other than his latest win.

He is up there as 1 of the best 6 fighters in boxing: Usyk, Fury, Canelo, Spence, Inoue, Lomachenko. In no particular order. I think those are the best P4P fighters right now.

If Bivol can beat Beterbiev, he deserves to be called top 5 P4P as well.

I’m flexible with the P4P list. I don’t believe in just dropping and raising fighters for no matter who they lost to or who they beat. I think that’s really unfair that some guy KO’s a 40 year old, moves up in the list, but some other fighter loses to a young, prime, undefeated fighter and just gets dropped and forgotten (Lomachenko-Lopez). It’s nonsense imo. Then P4P fighters should just duck the best, prime fighters and go on a Senior tour just beating up on old or past prime fighters and keep moving up in the P4P ranks.

If an unbeaten fighter was to beat a fairly consensus P4P number one who was cleaning out divisions up and down the scale....you wouldn't place that fighter above the one he beat?