Comments Thread For: Katie Taylor vs. Amanda Serrano - LIVE BoxingScene Scorecard

[Superbee]

That 5th round deserved a 10-8 Serrano ... Draw at the most if not a Serrano win ... I had it 96-93 Serrano...

Also... 3 mins rounds please... This might lead to shorter fights, but that's what it should be... Taylor would have not been able to get out of the 5th...

[stellen]

It was a very close fight. But i gave it to Serrano. There has to be a rematch surely.

[WamBamSam23]

That 5th round deserved a 10-8 Serrano ... Draw at the most if not a Serrano win ... I had it 96-93 Serrano...

Also... 3 mins rounds please... This might lead to shorter fights, but that's what it should be... Taylor would have not been able to get out of the 5th...

Hurdidurh the fighter we like lost so let’s change the rules easy fight to score 7-3 or 6-4 Katie the GWOAT.

[MHarris71]

There is no way Taylor won the fight..At best she could argue a draw.

[Hugekcoc]

I thought serrano was going to knock her out. What happened this so called power? Taylor won 7-3 in my opinion, maybe 6-4 but correct result.

[Superbee]

Hurdidurh the fighter we like lost so let’s change the rules easy fight to score 7-3 or 6-4 Katie the GWOAT.

10-8 rounds with no counts happen... Always did... And was pretty close to that if you ask me ... Taylor was almost out on her feet ...

[billeau2]

Hurdidurh the fighter we like lost so let’s change the rules easy fight to score 7-3 or 6-4 Katie the GWOAT.

You keep saying that... in two threads? no... People can make a great case that either won that fight... Live with it.

[kuryant2012]

i actually dont mind the boxing scene scorecard (95-95). I had serrano winning and thought she clearly won rd 10, outlanding katie and landing the harder punches. I still cant believe all 3 judges gave it to katie. if it was a men's fight the man doing what amanda did would have easily been given the rd. But i had katie winning rd 1 and rds 7-9. And i have no problem with boxing scene giving katie rd 2 as well. All other rds were clear amanda rds in my opinion.

[Cerebral Man]

I had it 5-5 in rounds, but gave Serrano a 10-8 round in the 5th. There are many less knockdowns in women's boxing so a round as dominant as Serrano's should be counted as a 10-8 round, which would have given the fight to Serrano, 95-94. Credit Taylor for staying on her feet and coming back, an amazing show of endurance and heart, and certainly her victory is deserved even with my scores a bit different. I do think we need to look at 10-8 rounds for non-knockdown dominance.