Worse decision: Canelo-GGG1 or Floyd-Castillo1

[Rad]

The two most controversial fights of both Floyd and Canelo’s career….

Which one was more of a robbery (if at all) in your opinion and why?

[LeOoze]

Neither were bad decisions imo. I had Canelo winning the first 3 and last 3 rounds. Maybe Canelo should have been given the nod. I also thought Floyd won

[GhostofDempsey]

Both were pretty bad. The Canelo/GGG fight was a higher profile fight, but they were equally incompetent/corrupt decisions.

[Emperor Trump]

Both were bad. But Floyd-Castillo was a lot worse.

[Johnny2x2x]

I thought the first Castillo-Mayweather fight was easy to score 7-5 for Mayweather. He was ahead Maybe 6-0 before he hurt his shoulder. Not a bad decision at all.

gGG-Canelo 1 was a close fight that was a draw at best for GGG. I scored it a draw.

[famicommander]

Floyd won, GGG won. That's how I scored them at the time and that's how I scored them on rewatch.

[lopetego]

Floyd-Castillo by far, that was a highway robbery

[Johnny2x2x]

Floyd-Castillo by far, that was a highway robbery

I’m always curious when someone says this, what rounds did Castillo win? There’s simply no way to find 7 rounds for Castillo, none. And finding 6 rounds for him is really hard too.

[Boxing-1013]

I’m always curious when someone says this, what rounds did Castillo win? There’s simply no way to find 7 rounds for Castillo, none. And finding 6 rounds for him is really hard too.

Floyd wasn't up 6-0. It was more like 4-2. And the last 6 I could see being 3-3 as well. I had it 4-2 Floyd and 3-3. So 7-5 Floyd. But it was close.

[Boxing-1013]

GGG-Canelo was worse. Impossible really to get Canelo to 6 rounds. Whereas Floyd had 7 rounds on my card and the most rounds you could possibly give JLC, for me, would be 7.

Canelo struggles to even get 5 rounds on any sane person's card in that fight. Floyd gets at least 5 quite easily.