Has Manny surpassed Tito on the ATG list?

[strugler]

Outside of DLH(who actually won), I don't see his resume to be all that great. Camacho, Vargas...who else?

carr,reid, joppy, delahoya, blocker,

[6Bound]

I never really cared for Tito to be honest..

[Freddy Krueger]

You people should stop bring up titos name, I despise him so much. I can't believe how many ricans he has fooled with I'm an atg, mother ****er isn't even better then Cotto. Cotto ain't gotta cheat with his hand-wraps.

[street bully]

carr,reid, joppy, delahoya, blocker,

Oba Carr? lmao. Carr lost to each of the three best WWs of the late 90s in Quartey, Oscar, and Trinidad. Hardly a great win. Reid unproven, green, never did anything. Joppy, a great win. Titos biggest win IMO. De La Hoya, come on we all know Tito lost. That would be like saying Chavez got a draw with Whitaker.

[Mr. Fantastic]

carr,reid, joppy,blocker,

who???????????

[Dan...]

Pacquiao is already higher than Tito on the ATG list IMO.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

Tito is great only at 147..

pareng Katz, he was great at 154 when he beat the snot out of Vargas

[strugler]

Oba Carr? lmao. Carr lost to each of the three best WWs of the late 90s in Quartey, Oscar, and Trinidad. Hardly a great win. Reid unproven, green, never did anything. Joppy, a great win. Titos biggest win IMO. De La Hoya, come on we all know Tito lost. That would be like saying Chavez got a draw with Whitaker.

WTF..........CARR would decision clottey.............trinidad would KO all th WW today..........barnone.........except cotto he wins a close but clear decision......................

[flyest1]

Yes. Tito made a bad mistake retiring after the Hopkins loss. he should have moved down to 154, or even won a paper title at 168.

I agree, but he really didn't retire after Hop. Remember he faced Ceriffe I believe. But any way if he moved down to 154 which I knew he could have made. He could have had a match with Mosley who been calling him out for a while. He could have rematch Hoya. Both were money fights at the time. Mosley would've never fought Forrest either, lol.

[Mr. Fantastic]

WTF..........CARR would decision clottey.............trinidad would KO all th WW today..........barnone.........except cotto he wins a close but clear decision......................

I think a fight against a prime Mosley would of been great. One on the juice and the other one with suspect knuckles.

I don't think he would KO Clottey.