Who isn't actually undefeated Calzaghe or Mayweather Jr?

[Heru]

Calzaghe and Floyd are deffinitely comparable.

Calzaghe obtained 2 ring/regognised titles and remained unfefeated.

Floyd obtained 3 ring/regognised titles and remained undeafeted.

Both fought for ~40+ fights.

Calzaghe has good wins on his resume: Eubank, Reid, Kessler, Lacy, Hopkins, Jones (6)
Floyd has good wins on his: Hernandez, Gatti, Corrales, Castillo, Judah, Baldomir, Hatton, DLH. (8)

Both great fighters, both totally undeafeted (thus far).

The thing is: Calzaghe got both Ring titles in his last 3 fights. Floyd was shutting down and beating up fighter that had beaten Azumah Nelson in his 18th fight.

They are comparable, but Floyd clearly has a better resume and overall career with a handful less fights.

[Shattered Jaw]

The thing is: Calzaghe got both Ring titles in his last 3 fights. Floyd was shutting down and beating up fighter that had beaten Azumah Nelson in his 18th fight.

They are comparable, but Floyd clearly has a better resume and overall career with a handful less fights.

Yer but Calzaghe dominated Eubank early in his career who has beaten Benn who had beaten X who had beaten Y...

Anyway, you're right. I was just saying they were comparable.

[jpitt]

he'd still be better than calz imho.

Nah, don't think so.

[Fulcrum29]

Fact of the matter is very simple: EVERY SINGLE top fighter has had controversial decisions in their career, you just don't hear people whining about it because most of the other fighters aren't undefeated. In Floyd's case however, he instantly rematched Castillo and whooped his ass DECISIVELY so there really is nothing haters can say at all to discredit him because he silenced everyone when he wooped Castillo that 2nd time.

[King Flawless]

Don't compare Calzaghe to Floyd. Compare Calzaghe to Gatti or Hatton NOT FLOYD

[Equilibrium]

I can't talk about the Calzaghe one cause i haven't seen it.

But mayweather definitely lost to Castillo. I don't care what you Mayweather nuthuggers say, he lost, it will go down in history as if mayweather won that fight because boxing is a corrupt sport. But everybody knows mayweather lost.

[Jim Jeffries]

yea they're both undefeated... damn too bad they're not the same size to fight one another.. makes u wonder who's style would win since they're both great at adjusting on the fly.

Kinda weird that Paul Williams could fight and have an actual chance of beating both.

[Pullcounter]

Nah, don't think so.

no he is imho

[King Flawless]

Don't compare Calzaghe to Floyd. Compare Calzaghe to Gatti or Hatton NOT FLOYD

[Scott9945]

Don't compare Calzaghe to Floyd. Compare Calzaghe to Gatti or Hatton NOT FLOYD

Nice little race angle you got going there.