Comments Thread For: Roach on Mayweather's 50-0 Run: Pacquiao Had Better Quality of Wins

[ruedboy]

On his way out, Floyd put an exclamation point on his legacy with wins over Berto and McGregor.

[GrandpaBernard]

Floyd has a victory over a top 30 atg fighter when he schooled manny. manny lacks a win over a fighter that great

Both Alvarez and manny went on and continued to do great things after Floyd schooled em

manny’s win that aged well [Marquez] pales in comparison

[GrandpaBernard]

What difference does it make. None of those guys were in their prime.

The best ww Floyd beat in their prime was undefeated Ricky Hatton, and even he was a paper champ who moved up from junior middleweight and arguably lost to a ww contender in his only legit test.

Manny obliterated him in what, two rounds.

did I mention Floyd beat them all

manny didn’t

in fact manny got schooled then flattened by Marquez. Who wasn’t prime

[b Murphington]

Pat Lawlor beat Duran...and Camacho.

You prove nothing in saying this. Manny lost against his biggest rival. It’s a big loss.

That being said, I still would rank Manny higher on ATG status at this point. There is a difference between great and better. Floyd is better than Manny head to head. But Pacquiao is greater. Do you understand?

[Richie_R]

Nothing but the truth for anyone with an iq above 100. However, we know that most of Floyd’s fans are low iq individuals.

[NachoMan]

You prove nothing in saying this. Manny lost against his biggest rival. It’s a big loss.

That being said, I still would rank Manny higher on ATG status at this point. There is a difference between great and better. Floyd is better than Manny head to head. But Pacquiao is greater. Do you understand?

Yeah, I do understand and agree. I thought you didn’t get that.

[djtmal]

did I mention Floyd beat them all

manny didn’t

in fact manny got schooled then flattened by Marquez. Who wasn’t prime

Did I mention that the best ww Floyd beat in their prime was undefeated Ricky Hatton. Who went on to do absolutely diddly at ww. Definitely not all time great material.

Last I checked Manny/Marquez went 2-1-1 in Manny's favor.

Marquez isn't an all time great. Is absolutely nobody @ ww. Its just a guy you Floyd boys like to keep in your mouth but in the grand scheme of things is nobody.

You cats love to pedestalize mediocrity. Marquez is a lw who outside of beating Manny 1x did absolutely nothing @ ww, but you cats seem to keep his name in your mouth like he is on a Srl/Hearns level but the truth is he would barely crack top 50 @ ww.

[GrandpaBernard]

Did I mention that the best ww Floyd beat in their prime was undefeated Ricky Hatton. Who went on to do absolutely diddly at ww. Definitely not all time great material.

Last I checked Manny/Marquez went 2-1-1 in Manny's favor.

Marquez isn't an all time great. Is absolutely nobody @ ww. Its just a guy you Floyd boys like to keep in your mouth but in the grand scheme of things is nobody.

You cats love to pedestalize mediocrity. Marquez is a lw who outside of beating Manny 1x did absolutely nothing @ ww, but you cats seem to keep his name in your mouth like he is on a Srl/Hearns level but the truth is he would barely crack top 50 @ ww.

Lol Marquez isn’t an atg and a nobody at welterweight

And beat manny twice at welterweight anyways

Says a lot about manny

[BillyBoxing]

Its simple Floyd is the better fighter, would beat Manny every day of the week and probably stop him as PBF around 130, all this who is greater is subjective opinion nothing more, when it really counted Floyd beat Manny in the ring, that's a fact and will always say Floyd is the better fighter.

Floyd beat Manny and Manny's best rival Marquez but he's naturally bigger than them.

Despite all the irrational fantasy talk that comes from Floyd's grupies that Floyd is not bigger because he could make 108 when he was 12 (lol), Manny is a blown up batamweight who at some point at flyweight and a smaller man.

Hagler and Hearns are not greater than Duran in most ATG lists despite the fact that they beat him.
Because Duran came from much lower weight than them and had some many great wins.

[djtmal]

Lol Marquez isn’t an atg and a nobody at welterweight

And beat manny twice at welterweight anyways

Says a lot about manny

He legitly beat Manny 1x after 4 fights they have been fighting each other since both were lws.

There's no shame in that.

Fighters do lose last I checked.

There's about 35-50 guys on all-time great lists who have losses, who are miles ahead of Floyd.

Manny beating prime Thurman a guy Floyd ducked, is far better than anything Floyd did @ ww.

Keep pedestalizing mediocrity thats it.