Comments Thread For: Judging The Judges: Gabriel Maestre-Mykal Fox Scorecard Analysis

[Bornboxingfan]

Wow, to much information to fast. My definition, expectation and respect of a Boxing Judge has been
blown apart. Being a hardcore fan, I booed the fight result but today my heart is sad and heavy.

[PBR Streetgang]

Yes we are all dying to hear your opinion...

Indeed. He can also weigh in with authority even when he doesn't watch a fight. It's really amazing.

[PBR Streetgang]

It is a little curious that the article focused on Martinez-Rizzo being a Trump supporter. I do understand mentioning the conflict of interest due to her husband's affiliation with the WBA, and her being a racist. The other two judges got the decision terribly wrong too. What was their excuse?

Yeah, I don't really understand the correlation they are trying to make regarding the Trump narrative.

She made some terrible, racist remarks and her affiliation with the WBA is another issue. The fact that she's a Trump supporter is a red herring to me.

[Alan Smithee]

Well if she is a Trump supporter then I demand an audit of her scorecard. Probably will be the same reult of the election audit. A big fat nothing. One thing boxing and politics have in common? Corruption! She was the WBA judge of the year,lol? The more things change, the more they stay the same!

[roademier]

Yeah, I don't really understand the correlation they are trying to make regarding the Trump narrative.

She made some terrible, racist remarks and her affiliation with the WBA is another issue. The fact that she's a Trump supporter is a red herring to me.

Internet reporting at it's most professional best...

[Slowhand]

Racism and especially being from the fighters home country are reasons to be su****ious of judges but being a Trump supporter makes one dishonest and corrupt?
I'm guessing being a Trump hater makes Bob Arum the most honest guy in boxing. lol

True, kind of. Being a Trump supporter makes one a gullible idiot, but that shouldn´t matter as long as the score cards are fair. In this case the Trumpette clearly is dishonest and corrupt and I wouldn´t waste too much energy defending her.

[KayoKid77]

Obviously, none of the judges involved in the Fox-Maestre fiasco should ever be permitted to judge again, but it is unfortunate that the "journalist" of this article had to inject his leftist bias into the conversation. For the record, Trump hired more ********** in his companies than all prior Presidents combined. Secondly, Clinton was also "impeached." If she had been a Clinton supporter, would that have also been an indication of her corruption. BoxingScene disserves better than the moronic conclusions of this "journalist." Perhaps the Daily Worker could use his services.

[PunchyPotorff]

Here come the rear-end hurt 45aholics desperately trying to defend their lord-and-master 45. Dig... it's the way journalism is supposed to be... bringing up FACTS in this and other articles exposing all angles of the corruption/bias in judges. Embarrassingly, 45 cultists are all about feelings, not facts.

[BoxingIsGreat]

BoxingScene reporters should be key to getting this woman banned from doing anything in judging, boxing or not. We need follow up articles. Expose all her relations and boxing connections. It's the job of any conscientious, adventurous boxing writer to do. Make your position matter. Ask the hard questions without even thinking about losing your credentials. This woman is trash.

[BoxingIsGreat]

Jake, well-written, as always. It'd be nice if you don't drop this. Ask more questions about her status and the crooked WBA's "investigation" into nothing. I want to read more about what they think of her racist and barbaric views. Before her posts were deleted, I saw one post where she says: "Jail is a comfort, take her out." How can this be a judge of anything?

Monkey face? If you address the presidential family like that, you get killed in most countries (countries like her origin).

You can use my post to approach the question: A fan on BoxingScene wants to know..... see above.