YAHOO SPORTS!! Has Paul Williams P4P Number 3..............

[fdotorres]

It shouldn't just be about who's more proven. On ability I could argue Paul Williams is number 1 already. But I won't do that until he has more quality wins.

after getting schooled by quintana, he avenged his only loss in great fashion

what has he done after that. i've seen him fight against 3 old guys, the best of them baing a 37 year old boxer coming from a 2 year lay off and a loss

please explain to me: what has he done after beating quintana?

LOL

[fdotorres]

Your argument against Williams would hold more weight if he wasn't already a 3 time World Champion. He's definitely proven enough to arguably be ranked this high. On a combination of his ability and what he's already done, he's top 3 for me.

his only title defense was a loss... how does that make you p4p #3????

[Heru]

He's been #3 for a while. He shouldn't be that high up until he beats #1 or 2 in a division. Think about it, he hasn't beaten 1 #1 yet (Wright was unranked, not sure if Margarito was #2 or 3) but whatever, it's their opinion so it is what it is.

[Matt Marvelous]

I'm not going to waste my time defending my opinion with people who aren't going to accept it no matter what I say. Obviously I'm not the only boxing fan who believes Paul is this good. I make my own lists with my own criteria.

[fdotorres]

I'm not going to waste my time defending my opinion with people who aren't going to accept it no matter what I say. Obviously I'm not the only boxing fan who believes Paul is this good. I make my own lists with my own criteria.

exactly, don't waste your time

[El Angel]

I think that's a little high right now based on his accomplishments so far in his career, but he can definitely reach this plateau.

[_original_]

Hey it's their list, their list is as good as anybodys....some people just can't understand that p4p list are not set in stone or real rankings per say....all the boxing fans and boxing writers have different ones....

[TheCheetah]

He's in the top 3 for me as well. In the light middleweight division he's rated number 1 according to BoxRec

[Danny Gunz]

4 of the biggest boxing stars are crying about catchweights,while the Punisher is literally roaming 3 weight classes looking to fight the best & all his haters can do is ask why he's ranked so high by Yahoo??Well maybe they see what simple people can't,at least someone is pound for pounding on a literal scale between 3 weight classes!!

that is actually a great point that i never thought of.

You literally changed my opinion, the way he is looking for any fights in all these weight classes makes him a legit top 5 p4p until someone takes his fights and beats him

[_original_]

He's in the top 3 for me as well. In the light middleweight division he's rated number 1 according to BoxRec

Not sure if you've noticed this, but boxrec rankings are a ****ing joke!..only good thing they serve for is for looking up a fighters resume and seeing when the fights took place.....