Vitali or Wlad would RETIRE toney

[The Gully Gad]

I like Toney..I even think a Hata would'nt wanna see VK or Vlad beat on him...

Right guys?

lol

[DiLLiNGER]

thats what i love about toney,hes what boxing should be all about,he loves the sport,he would fight with one of his arms missing

[Junito-Rulez]

Toney is da man, ain't noboy retire his ass easily. The K bros always ducked him. They might stop him but Toney won't quit on his stool and, contrary to Haye, he has balls. He can talk a hundred time funnier talk than Haye and walk the walk like the true man he is.

Haye is just **** scared of both Klitschko. Vitali punched his shoulder and Haye looked down like a lil kid.

[Klitschko2011]

Toney is an overrated fat racist punk

Samuel Peter dominated Toney and knocked him down with a jab.

Toney gets DESTROYED by either Klitschko

[Junito-Rulez]

Toney is an overrated fat racist punk

Samuel Peter dominated Toney knocked him down with a jab.

Toney gets DESTROYED by either Klitschko

Fat: yes
Racist:yes
punk:yes
Overrated: Hell no. Do you know someone who was a top middleweight and who climbed his way up to the heavyweight division beating up people left and right. Contrary to Roy he fought the best and was a real heavyweight.
The man beat: Holyfield, Barkley, Ruiz, Jirov, Mccallum, Reggie Johnson, and Michael Nunn.

Skillwise he's a top 3 in the last 20 years.

[The Hammer]

so he should be glad they "ducking" him, they'd give him permanent injuries!

This is correct. Toney probably knows it himself, he just likes to hype himself with talk.

[pantera713]

Correction, Toney whooped Peter's ass in the first fight. I don't award points for hitting arms and shoulders and also don't give points for missing punches, all those little flurries at the end of the rounds in the first fight, Toney made Peter miss almost all of those punches. True, Peter dominated him in the rematch but the first fight was Toney's no ****ing doubt.


James Toney will always be one of my favorites, no matter what. I think it's amazing that such a smaller man can move up through all of those weight classes and still hang with much bigger and taller men. His defensive skills and counter punching are amazing, you just don't see that in todays boxers.

True though, i think Vitali could beat Toney.

[The Hammer]

Fat: yes
Racist:yes
punk:yes
Overrated: Hell no. Do you know someone who was a top middleweight and who climbed his way up to the heavyweight division beating up people left and right. Contrary to Roy he fought the best and was a real heavyweight.
The man beat: Holyfield, Barkley, Ruiz, Jirov, Mccallum, Reggie Johnson, and Michael Nunn.

Skillwise he's a top 3 in the last 20 years.

He also lost to Thadzi, Peter x 2, Griffin x 2, and had a draw with Sanderline Williams, who had lost 5 of his previous 6 fights. He was schooled by Roy Jones.

Tiberi was robbed in his fight with Toney. "Belly's Out" received gift decisions in several other fights: Oquendo and clubfighter Batchelder, for example.

He twice got caught using steroids for title fights. Someone who's top 3 of the past 20 years wouldn't have needed steroids to beat Batchelder and Ruiz.

[PittyPat]

"Belly's Out" received gift decisions in several other fights

See Tuns, you can be a pretty funny guy when you're not so busy Haye-ting.

[TheCheetah]

James Toney is a legend I don't see how some of you can sit here and say he's a bum....