What Does a COTTO Win over MANNY PACQUIAO Mean?

Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • VaBoriKua 2.0
    Banned
    • Aug 2007
    • 3995
    • 110
    • 47
    • 4,417

    #81
    Originally posted by Horus
    In that case you must think Gayweathers win over hatton was a great defense of his welterweight title. Since hatton was a former welterweight champion since Hatton challenge him ?

    But i know you would not be indicating that would you?
    theres a big difference manny murdered oscar and made it look easy hatton looked like **** and most people though collazo won the fight anyways and they gave it to ricky hence y he never fought there after until the floyd fight

    Comment

    • VaBoriKua 2.0
      Banned
      • Aug 2007
      • 3995
      • 110
      • 47
      • 4,417

      #82
      Originally posted by Horus
      Gayweather came back to fight blown up lightweights at ww
      and called it a welterweight fight and to count it as a great win for his legacy ..

      but to set the record straight.
      you think a cotto win over pacquiao is a great win for cotto?
      lets put it like this a cotto win over manny is a wayyyyyyyy better win than a floyd win or jmm manny has tested 147 and was dominating135 140 147 when he fought there jmm wasnt dominating at 135 he did win both his fights but they were both close were he was getting hit alot and were battles not one sided beatdowns like manny does. manny tested ww before and dominated jmm never fought above 135 and wasnt dominating at that weight either

      Comment

      • t.boone.pickenz
        Interim Champion
        Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
        • Sep 2008
        • 773
        • 26
        • 31
        • 7,866

        #83
        Originally posted by Horus
        There you go
        I'm serious, dirty neck Pac already ****d Dlh (one of the greatest welters ever) in five rounds and gave hatton a Cleveland steamer in 2 rounds.......what else do you need?????

        Comment

        • Horus
          Greatest Of My Era
          • Dec 2007
          • 10220
          • 772
          • 112
          • 18,146

          #84
          Originally posted by VaBoriKua 2.0
          theres a big difference manny murdered oscar and made it look easy hatton looked like **** and most people though collazo won the fight anyways and they gave it to ricky hence y he never fought there after until the floyd fight
          OHHHHHHHHHHHH....I see
          A pacquiao win over a weight drain zombie oscar is a better win
          than a win over the A Prime WBA champion Collazo?

          ohhhhhhhhhhhhh....




          Comment

          • VaBoriKua 2.0
            Banned
            • Aug 2007
            • 3995
            • 110
            • 47
            • 4,417

            #85
            Originally posted by Horus
            OHHHHHHHHHHHH....I see
            A pacquiao win over a weight drain zombie oscar is a better win
            than a win over the A Prime WBA champion Collazo?

            ohhhhhhhhhhhhh....




            who won more convincingly? PPL THOUGH COLLAZO Won ANYWAYS hater im done with u ur just a clown

            Comment

            • Horus
              Greatest Of My Era
              • Dec 2007
              • 10220
              • 772
              • 112
              • 18,146

              #86
              Originally posted by VaBoriKua 2.0
              lets put it like this a cotto win over manny is a wayyyyyyyy better win than a floyd win or jmm manny has tested 147 and was dominating135 140 147 when he fought there jmm wasnt dominating at 135 he did win both his fights but they were both close were he was getting hit alot and were battles not one sided beatdowns like manny does. manny tested ww before and dominated jmm never fought above 135 and wasnt dominating at that weight either
              Pacquiao is not a WELTERWEIGHT....
              Pacquiao best weight is not WELTERWEIGHT
              Pacquiao never fought a PRIME welterweight

              So how is a Pacquiao win at WELTERWEIGHT a great win and not a mediocre one? since Pacquiao is a blown up lightweight?

              More importantly why is Cotto fighting blown up lightweights at ww, when he could be fighting deserving fighters at WW would love to fight him...

              If cotto wants to fight blown up lightweights he should fight at lightweight

              dont you agree..?

              Like Mangler reminds us everyday
              Originally posted by mangler
              Fights wit Pac are fine if they happen at 140. Simple as that. If you wanna fight at WW, fight a ****in WW.

              Comment

              • Horus
                Greatest Of My Era
                • Dec 2007
                • 10220
                • 772
                • 112
                • 18,146

                #87
                Originally posted by VaBoriKua 2.0
                who won more convincingly? PPL THOUGH COLLAZO Won ANYWAYS hater im done with u ur just a clown

                If a fighter moves up and fights a Mediocre fighters at a higher weight effectively and look good doing it. does that now mean they prove they can fight beat everybody at that weight class...???

                When Roy beat John Ruiz at Heavyweight, did that mean he can also beat Lennox lewis??? Because Roy Proved he can fight effectively and look good at Heavyweight against a good fighter.

                and on the other side

                If a fighter moves up and fights real good competition but doesnt look impressive doing it, does it now mean he shouldnt fight at that weight?

                I mean some fighters you just not going to look good against period.

                Thats has nothing to do with you, but it has everything to do with the other fighter.

                I mean look at Floyd first fight at 135 pounds...against Castillo..
                Floyd didnt look impressive at all winning that fight ... but did that mean he should of moved back down to 130??? because he wasnt effective at 135 as he was at 130???

                Of Course not...!!!

                do you get the point?

                being effective has to do with your opponent very little with the fighter..!!


                Luis Collazo is not a bum and he is a very difficult fighter to beat especially if that is your FIRST fight at Welterweight. Like it was for Ricky Hatton.



                I am pretty sure JMM can look impressive at WW if he fought Delvin Rodriguez and Michael Jennings instead of Mayweather too but that is not the point.

                Your Opponent is the deciding factor in a fighter looking effective not the fighter most of the time

                Comment

                • t.boone.pickenz
                  Interim Champion
                  Gold Champion - 500-1,000 posts
                  • Sep 2008
                  • 773
                  • 26
                  • 31
                  • 7,866

                  #88
                  Originally posted by Horus
                  Pacquiao is not a WELTERWEIGHT....
                  Pacquiao best weight is not WELTERWEIGHT
                  Pacquiao never fought a PRIME welterweight

                  So how is a Pacquiao win at WELTERWEIGHT a great win and not a mediocre one? since Pacquiao is a blown up lightweight?

                  More importantly why is Cotto fighting blown up lightweights at ww, when he could be fighting deserving fighters at WW would love to fight him...

                  If cotto wants to fight blown up lightweights he should fight at lightweight

                  dont you agree..?

                  Like Mangler reminds us everyday
                  dlh was prime ......he goon-ishly made weight 4 months before the fight.. if that isn't prime i don't know what is.........

                  Comment

                  • MaD RoBoT
                    Undisputed Champion
                    Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
                    • Sep 2008
                    • 3892
                    • 664
                    • 362
                    • 17,466

                    #89
                    Originally posted by Horus
                    Gayweather came back to fight blown up lightweights at ww
                    and called it a welterweight fight and to count it as a great win for his legacy ..

                    but to set the record straight.
                    you think a cotto win over pacquiao is a great win for cotto?

                    Comment

                    • Horus
                      Greatest Of My Era
                      • Dec 2007
                      • 10220
                      • 772
                      • 112
                      • 18,146

                      #90
                      Originally posted by BUL@H@W
                      I still want to know What Does a Cotto Win over Manny Pacquiao Mean to you In your opinion?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP