who thinks castillo beat floyd on their first fight?

[flyest1]

LOL...youre crazy...they fought twice by then................

he didnt want that third fight with him. Alot of people felt JMM won both fights. I think they both should have been draws. But JMM has been on Pac's ass for a rematch. The sad thing is Floyd is letting JMM get a big money fight.

[Silencers]

I thought Castillo won but it was a close fight.

[el malo]

This fight will always be disputed, but still...



Lederman scores it 115-111 Castillo

Lampley comments after the decision (and a lot of booing from the crowd) "not the fight we saw, definitely not the fight this crew saw"

Compubox numbers:
Castillo 506 thrown 203 landed powerpunches landed 173
Mayweather 448 thrown 157 landed powerpunches landed 66

this pretty much sums it up, castillo won in all eyes except for the three judges. castillo should've definitely got the decision.

[badboypeenoy]

I already seen it many times. Post your scorecard that's all I'm asking you.

Rounds 1
Mayweather

Round 2
Castillo slips, clash of heads
Mayweather

Round 3
Mayweather

Round 4
Mayweather

Round 5
Castillo

Round 6
Mayweather slips
Castillo

Round 7
Castillo

Round 8
Castillo deducted a point for punching on the break
Draw

Round 9
Castillo

Round 10
Mayweather deducted a point
for pushing off with an elbow
Castillo 10-8

Round 11
Castillo

Round 12
Castillo

[Bhopreign]

Funny nobody ever brings up the obvious hurt shoulder. Said he had cracked ribs going into that fight also.

[el malo]

Rounds 1
Mayweather

Round 2
Castillo slips, clash of heads
Mayweather

Round 3
Mayweather

Round 4
Mayweather

Round 5
Castillo

Round 6
Mayweather slips
Castillo

Round 7
Castillo

Round 8
Castillo deducted a point for punching on the break
Draw

Round 9
Castillo

Round 10
Mayweather deducted a point
for pushing off with an elbow
Castillo 10-8

Round 11
Castillo

Round 12
Castillo

115-111 castillo that sounds about right.

[el malo]

Funny nobody ever brings up the obvious hurt shoulder. Said he had cracked ribs going into that fight also.

ok so you agree he lost because of a hurt shoulder and cracked ribs?

[Bhopreign]

ok so you agree he lost because of a hurt shoulder and cracked ribs?

No, I scored this fight for the13thround dotcom and had Floyd winning 114-113.

[_original_]

Thousands of years from now...frustrated Mayweather haters will still be talking about this fight like if it wasn't even close.

You bring up Ali, SRL, etc. Why you do that for? It's about the bitching, i'm not saying to forget history. It's the damn bitching. You know the bitching that your girlfriend brings up about how she dislikes your ex-girlfriend, the one before her? and she won't let it go?...the bitching, guys, the bitching...Let it go.

hey man my bad, maybe my post was very douchebag-like...but the reason I guess this talk is still relevent is because Floyd remains one of the best, if not the best fighter in world and has no losses....and he does a good job at reminding us every chance he gets that he's undefeated.....it's the closest thing we have to talk about him not being untouchable....but I agree, the bitc.hing gets annoying, but nothing wrong with disecting it though

[larry smith]

how hypocrite for *****s to say marquez beat pacman, when castillo beat floyd..