Where do you have Pacquiao in the ATG Top list???

[BrushMyCage]

Top 50.........


I dont rate Diaz..Oscar and Hatton as great wins........

He struggled with JMM...both times..........

the top 10 boxers struggled too...

[Burner]

Why not Hatton?

He looked weight drained...new trainer...floyd ruined him..lazcano almost knocked him out......

Cotto...Maywetaher...and Mosley are GREAT wins..

[badboypeenoy]

even the haters agree he's an ATG.

[rao007]

He looked weight drained...new trainer...floyd ruined him..lazcano almost knocked him out......

Cotto...Maywetaher...and Mosley are GREAT wins..

Floyd Mayweather Sr. did not ruin Hatton--as many used the Malignaggi fight as benchmark how well Hatton would do against speedy guys. Hatton simply forgot EVERYTHING Mayweather Sr. told him when he faced Pacquiao that night and fought exactly the way he did against Mayweather Jr.

[strugler]

IF................that a huge IF he beats PBF and MAC in impressive fashion..about 10-20............

even the haters agree he's an ATG.

Well there seems to be no option for "below top 50".

[JM1]

Top 50.........


I dont rate Diaz..Oscar and Hatton as great wins........

He struggled with JMM...both times..........

you mentioned 3 different fighters, then puts jmm to discredit pac. thats 5 different fights with different opponents. what the hell are you trying to do? you dont make sense at all

[cyutetrick]

hard to say where manny is at, there have been way... to many great fighters, but he is definately an atg and someone that people will remember for years after he retires maybe even forever!

[JAS_JAS]

1 of 2 fighters to be champion in 6 divisions, the only fighter to win 4 lineal championships, started from 106 all the way to 147, destroyed boxing legends like they were tune ups, did not duck anyone and challenged himself to his limits, one of the best, humblest and exciting fighter ever to lace up the gloves. now that is an ATG

[chinoy]

People who would put Pacquiao into the top five all time already either know NOTHING about the history of boxing or are doing incredible mental gymnastics to get him there. He's a bona fide ATG in my opinion, but he ain't catching the Armstorng, Greb, Robinson, Langford...he's gonna' have a hell of a time catching Duran. He's doing the right things but he's got a ways to go.

Cliff, where do you honestly put him in the ATG list currently?


a third reason could be that a majority of fans here in BS who put him in the top 5 are just being sarcastic who just like to tease the Pac haters.....