Did BUDDY McGIRT destroy PAULIE MALIGNAGGI? POLL

[LA BAD BOY]

I mean Malignaggi look in my opinion every fight worse with McGirt
in his corner.

Whats your opinion did McGirt destroyed PAULIE?

[larry x]

no paulie was never a world beater.....

[Doctor_Tenma]

Paulie is a feather fisted one handed fighter.

[BrendanWoodside]

paulie is afraid to throw the right hand for fear of breaking it. nothing to do with buddy.

[The Surgeon]

Not Buddys fault, Paullie just wasnt that great and his hands have made him a bit of a joke now

[The_Demon]

nothing to do with buddy
the guy had brittle hands and doesnt hit hard,also takes too many punches for a guy with his style
i was quite shocked at how many people thought he would beat hatton to be honest

[The Surgeon]

nothing to do with buddy
the guy had brittle hands and doesnt hit hard,also takes too many punches for a guy with his style
i was quite shocked at how many people thought he would beat hatton to be honest

So was i, he never had a chance did he! No power to keep Ricky off and he is no where near as slick as a guy with his style and strength/power needs to be

[Silkstone]

nothing to do with buddy
the guy had brittle hands and doesnt hit hard,also takes too many punches for a guy with his style
i was quite shocked at how many people thought he would beat hatton to be honest

I agree. McGirt did not destroy Paulie. Paulie was never going to be in the elite. I do think that there could have been a better trainer for him. Buddy wasn't the best pick, not at all. That being said, to place blame on Buddy for Paulie's shortcomings is nothing short of absurd, the chap did the best he could with Paulie.

[The_Demon]

So was i, he never had a chance did he! No power to keep Ricky off and he is no where near as slick as a guy with his style and strength/power needs to be

cotto showed that a strong guy would bust paulie up,and that was a weight-drained cotto.his speed was impressive but he would have been better off as a lightweight

[BoxingChaos]

Lou Dibully destroyed Paulie Malignaggi. How are going to throw Malignaggi against Cotto? That was a terrible mistake on Dibully. Credit to Paulie for trying but Paulie got lucky Cotto broke his hand if not, the beating might have been worse.