Would CALZAGHE be TOP 10 ATG if he would be AMERICAN? POLL

[TredKiller]

there are 4 people so far that say yes,

are you people sirious, has common boxing knowledge gone out the window??

he doesnt even have a resume better then bhop or rj,

my top 10:

Ali
robinson
armstrong
louis
pep
moore
greb
duran
foreman
leonard

tell me which one of those fighters does calzghe's resume top?

[Seiko]

no the only legit names on his record are past their prime fighters in eubank jones and hopkins

[Ray Ray]

there are 4 people so far that say yes,

are you people sirious, has common boxing knowledge gone out the window??

he doesnt even have a resume better then bhop or rj,

my top 10:

Ali
robinson
armstrong
louis
pep
moore
greb
duran
foreman
leonard

tell me which one of those fighters does calzghe's resume top?

Finally somebody that sees what I'm trying to imply...No one can question his greatness at SMW but as an overall P4P fighter...His resume doesnt hold up to the past ATG. Good post by the way!

[johnm is...]

Joe C is retired. To hell wit it.

Just so I'm clear on this..

Your stance is... No catch weights, and no discussing retired boxers?

[LA BAD BOY]

there are 4 people so far that say yes,

are you people sirious, has common boxing knowledge gone out the window??

he doesnt even have a resume better then bhop or rj,

my top 10:

Ali
robinson
armstrong
louis
pep
moore
greb
duran
foreman
leonard

tell me which one of those fighters does calzghe's resume top?

YOU FORGOT that he beat B-HOP in AMERICA.

And everyone said:he beat old man.

But old man year later smash KELLY PAVLIK.

[TredKiller]

Finally somebody that sees what I'm trying to imply...No one can question his greatness at SMW but as an overall P4P fighter...His resume doesnt hold up to the past ATG. Good post by the way!

thanx bro,

i think the only people that say yes,

are the ones that have only been watching boxing for about a year.

[TredKiller]

YOU FORGOT that he beat B-HOP in AMERICA.

And everyone said:he beat old man.

But old man year later smash KELLY PAVLIK.

your point, he still dont have a better resume then the ten i mentioned.

[Ray Ray]

Just so I'm clear on this..

Your stance is... No catch weights, and no discussing retired boxers?

It never seem to fail with him...he's the forum police it seems...No discussing retired fighters or catchweights because he said so!

What type of **** is that?? This is a boxing forum right??

[Ray Ray]

thanx bro,

i think the only people that say yes,

are the ones that have only been watching boxing for about a year.

Exactly...I'm not trying to **** on Joe Cal. by any means but me pesonally I dont see how his resume will hold up to the pas ATG...I seriously dont.

[TredKiller]

Exactly...I'm not trying to **** on Joe Cal. by any means but me pesonally I dont see how his resume will hold up to the pas ATG...I seriously dont.

i could name 70 fighters that have better resume's then joe, it just a fact.