Vic Darchiniyan should not be moved down the P4P list more than one spot.

[-Hyperion-]

Margarito was no where near P4P when he fougth Cotto. Anyways this is about Vic, and he didn't lose in his own weight class.

he lost 3 pounds up and weighed 130lb, he is clearly small as **** for bantam.......

[-Swizzy-]

I'm kinda 50/50 on this issue, its a bit of a tough one.

same


sure Darch should get credit for moving up, but he didn't exactly move up 10 pounds and Agbeko is good, but he isn't great. I don't know what to think of this loss.

[-Hyperion-]

Margarito was no where near P4P when he fougth Cotto. Anyways this is about Vic, and he didn't lose in his own weight class.

nowhere near p4p??lol.........of course he was.....theres areason he was ranked as high as #6 as soon as he won.........raheem beat #4 p4p ranked morales and didnt get to the ratings, so clearly margarito had some good work behind him.

shane mosley is #5 p4p becuase of a victory over margarito, a victory over agbeko wont get you in the top 15 unless you have impressive work previously......

[street bully]

nowhere near p4p??lol.........of course he was.....theres areason he was ranked as high as #6 as soon as he won.........raheem beat #4 p4p ranked morales and didnt get to the ratings, so clearly margarito had some good work behind him.

shane mosley is #5 p4p becuase of a victory over margarito, a victory over agbeko wont get you in the top 15 unless you have impressive work previously......

But Cotto's loss to margarito, and his fight over the great Michael Jennings who was considered the WW version of George Foreman was enought to get Cotto back into the mid P4P range? **** that.

[-Hyperion-]

But Cotto's loss to margarito, and his fight over the great Michael Jennings who was considered the WW version of George Foreman was enought to get Cotto back into the mid P4P range? **** that.

umm given the high su****ion of plaster use, the fact that cotto looked the way more skillfull fighter in his loss, and the fact that he held a clear victory over the #5 p4p, how is it crazy, if anything he should be above mosley, who he outclassed(and i'm a shane nuthugger).....

[street bully]

umm given the high su****ion of plaster use, the fact that cotto looked the way more skillfull fighter in his loss, and the fact that he held a clear victory over the #5 p4p, how is it crazy, if anything he should be above mosley, who he outclassed(and i'm a shane nuthugger).....

So what was Mijares's rank before Vic iced him, and what was molsey's rank? uess which one wa sranked higher.

And plaster my ass. Su****ion doesn't mean **** if you can not prove it. The better man won that fight end of, and he would win againand again.

[-Hyperion-]

So what was Mijares's rank before Vic iced him, and what was molsey's rank? uess which one wa sranked higher.

And plaster my ass. Su****ion doesn't mean **** if you can not prove it. The better man won that fight end of, and he would win againand again.

mijares was #9........dropped out of the rankings after the loss.....hell i recognised vic as more deserving than say celestino caballero or ivan calderon, i had him at #10.....now he lost against an unproven title holder, so he drops out, end of.....thats what happens when a fringe p4p losses to somene who is not even close to it....

[taino78]

The guy took a gamble, moving up yet another weight class to fight a tough as nail opponant with an iron chin, and he just came up a little short. It was a competitive fight, and even though he lost by a wide margin, he was always in the fight and gave it 110%. It is not as if he lost to someone in his own weight division. King Kong is a beast, and was being overlooked by most. Anyways fighters have lost in humiliating fashion before to weak competion, and have quit not to be moved down much the P4P list, and I do not think Vac should have to suffer for daring to be great, and conquering yet another weight class.

Even thought I was behing Agbeko, and chose him to win I realize that Vic is a warrior, and should not be moved down more than one or two places on the list.

if he dont move up anymore he should be fine cause i see a lot more beatings in his future if he does.

[street bully]

mijares was #9........dropped out of the rankings after the loss.....hell i recognised vic as more deserving than say celestino caballero or ivan calderon, i had him at #10.....now he lost against an unproven title holder, so he drops out, end of.....thats what happens when a fringe p4p losses to somene who is not even close to it....

Mijares was ranked number 8 or number 7 not 9, also Darchy lost ABOVE his own weight class.

[Mr.Fantastic]

Who cares about the P4P right now!! Its so fucking ****ty!!

We have a 3-3 guy with no belt on number 3.
We have a guy who doesn't deserve to be number 4.
We have Vazquez
Marquez(who is 2-2 last 4 fights) on there.
Cotto wins and drops 2 spots.
Donaire doesn't deserve to be on there.