Would a decisive win over Pac decide whether Cotto is better than JMM?

[dondi330]

I mean considering that Pac, JMM, and Cotto are about 5'7". They all have a 67" reach.
JMM tested or even "won" in some eyes but it was a close decision either way.
Observers cant say "Cotto was too big" because they are all equal in height, weight, and reach.
Many believe JMM is a far more superior boxer.
So given all this if Cotto flat out whoops Pac......will he be considered a better boxer than JMM?

[Doctor_Tenma]

I mean considering that Pac, JMM, and Cotto are about 5'7". They all have a 67" reach.
JMM tested or even "won" in some eyes but it was a close decision either way.
Observers cant say "Cotto was too big" because they are all equal in height, weight, and reach.
Many believe JMM is a far more superior boxer.
So given all this if Cotto flat out whoops Pac......will he be considered a better boxer than JMM?

It ain't about height/ reach only. Cotto has the much bigger frame, is the naturally bgger guy here. Though, this doesn't mean this ain't a great match up.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

No.

Styles, and circumstances makes fights!!!!!!!!

[AztecWanker]

It just means that Cotto matched up better against Pac than JMM.

[JACK D. RIPPER]

No. JMM is just the better skilled guy p4p.

[dondi330]

It ain't about height/ reach only. Cotto has the much bigger frame, is the naturally bgger guy here. Though, this doesn't mean this ain't a great match up.

No.

Styles, and circumstances makes fights!!!!!!!!

What more do you guys want ?
I mentioned boxing, weight, height, reach?
When I mentioned boxing it was to include, speed, combination's, chin, defense, etc...I didn't think I had to be so "ABC".
I understand style make fights. Most believe that JMM is a better boxer so the question stands?
As for frame?
You must not have seen the Margarito vs. Cotto frame difference.
or Paul Williams vs Quintana Frame difference...lol
Anyway I have never heard "frame" discussed in boxing.
Will that be the excuse if Pac loses?...."Cotto had a bigger frame"!...lol

[Doctor_Tenma]

What more do you guys want ?
I mentioned boxing, weight, height, reach?
When I mentioned boxing it was to include, speed, combination's, chin, defense, etc...I didn't think I had to be so "ABC".
I understand style make fights. Most believe that JMM is a better boxer so the question stands?
As for frame?
You must not have seen the Margarito vs. Cotto frame difference.
or Paul Williams vs Quintana Frame difference...lol
Anyway I have never heard "frame" discussed in boxing.
Will that be the excuse if Pac loses?...."Cotto had a bigger frame"!...lol

Frame has always come into play. Height/ reach isn't the only thing used to indicate the bigger guy.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

What more do you guys want ?
I mentioned boxing, weight, height, reach?
When I mentioned boxing it was to include, speed, combination's, chin, defense, etc...I didn't think I had to be so "ABC".
I understand style make fights. Most believe that JMM is a better boxer so the question stands?
As for frame?
You must not have seen the Margarito vs. Cotto frame difference.
or Paul Williams vs Quintana Frame difference...lol
Anyway I have never heard "frame" discussed in boxing.
Will that be the excuse if Pac loses?...."Cotto had a bigger frame"!...lol

I know, but Just because I beat Soy Dominicano and he beats you, that doesnt mean Me>>>>>>>>>You!!!!!!!

Other things come into play, like Resumes, performances, head to head match if one, skills, a lot of things!!

[dondi330]

Frame has always come into play. Height/ reach isn't the only thing used to indicate the bigger guy.

Show me a legitimate boxing article that discusse the "frame"...And I will shut up...lol

[dondi330]

I know, but Just because I beat Soy Dominicano and he beats you, that doesnt mean Me>>>>>>>>>You!!!!!!!

Other things come into play, like Resumes, performances, head to head match if one, skills, a lot of things!!

Ok, will just leave it at you beat dominicano soy.
But personally I believe that if Cotto can easily beat Pac, then he will easily beat JMM. Why?
I dont see JMM boxing circles around Cotto. IMO