Who took more risks in their career against the harder opposition

[Sox8055]

Cotto, even as a fan of Mayweather. However I have no doubt Mayweather beats him.

[ßringer]

Also, as much as I love him ; I wouldn't put Zab on either man's dangerous opposition list.

He'd already been beatdown twice by a pudgy dude with a rat tail, and a part time boxer who sold feather dusters for a living by the time Floyd beat his ass.

And 3 times by the time Cotto beat his ass.

Then again, you could also argue that with his speed, and stinging uppercut that Judah is always a threat in the ring.

I'd be inclined to agree with that, but only for the first 12 minutes.

[F l i c k e r]

Cotto:

Mosley, Margarito, Clottey, Judah, Quintana, Torres, Malignaggi, now possibly Pacquiao who has looked great against Oscar and hatton.

Floyd:

Oscar, Hatton, Castillo, Corrales, Gatti, Judah?

really? your serious?

[Flawed]

mayweather...........

[Flawed]

Cotto. BITD Mr boat buyer was a risk taker tho. But overall, Cotto did.

wrong.. mayweather is the p4p greatest of all time, unlike kneeguel quitto.

[F l i c k e r]

Also, as much as I love him ; I wouldn't put Zab on either man's dangerous opposition list.

He'd already been beatdown twice by a pudgy dude with a rat tail, and a part time boxer who sold feather dusters for a living by the time Floyd beat his ass.

And 3 times by the time Cotto beat his ass.

Then again, you could also argue that with his speed, and stinging uppercut that Judah is always a threat in the ring.

I'd be inclined to agree with that, but only for the first 12 minutes.

I put Zab for Mayweather because it was back when Zab was a threat, when he was still relevant to the title race. Cotto faught Zab when he was no longer relevant, when Zab became the guy to fight when someone needed a boost in their career.

[ACHlLLES]

really? your serious?

Malignaggi, is a good fighter, even Floyd called him a good fighter.

[venerablefist]

but we all now what floyd would have did to Malignaggi if they fought

[ßringer]

I put Zab for Mayweather because it was back when Zab was a threat, when he was still relevant to the title race. Cotto faught Zab when he was no longer relevant, when Zab became the guy to fight when someone needed a boost in their career.

I can see that.

But Zab was still coming off of being KTFO'd by Tszyu, and beat down for 12 rounds by an unknown named Baldomir who made his living by selling these things.

[ACHlLLES]

but we all now what floyd would have did to Malignaggi if they fought

Isn't that the excuse all Floyd fans give, well we know what would have happened if he had gotten in the ring with so and so.