Ring magazine Pound for pound? AGREE?

[AllEyesOpen]

I don't see why B-Hop is still high on that list, besides the Pavlik win he hasn't been looking all that great. Besides that i agree for the most part. Cotto & Mosley should both be alot closer to eachother on that list( & Mosley should be lower). Mosley lost to Cotto and showed his heart & skill against Margarito, Cotto lost to Margarito and showed his heart and skill against Clottey.

[baracuda]

pacman weight in fight night against david diaz 147. 12 pounds over the 135 weight limit

what's your point?...

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

why would you put jmm 1 wehn he didnt "beat" pacman while cotto beat him.

Because JMM have more recent accomplishment Compatre to Cotto, even if Cotto betas Pacquiao.

P4P, should be base, on skills, resume and accomplishment!!!!!!

You dont get a guys spot just because you beat him!!!!!!!!

[Chups]

Because JMM have more recent accomplishment Compatre to Cotto, even if Cotto betas Pacquiao.

P4P, should be base, on skills, resume and accomplishment!!!!!!

You dont get a guys spot just because you beat him!!!!!!!!

Good post.

[Mr.Fantastic]

I don't see why B-Hop is still high on that list, besides the Pavlik win he hasn't been looking all that great. Besides that i agree for the most part. Cotto & Mosley should both be alot closer to eachother on that list( & Mosley should be lower). Mosley lost to Cotto and showed his heart & skill against Margarito, Cotto lost to Margarito and showed his heart and skill against Clottey.

Hopkins is 3-3 in his last 6 fights, with no belt, AND he's been inactive lately. He's #3 for that?? Talk about low standards. Ring Ratings have been pretty pathetic lately. Ever since GBP took over it.

[Pullcounter]

Great ****ing Answer. Damn dumbass!!!!!!!

Cotto>>>>>>>Mosley until Mosley can prove Other wise, simple as that, Cpotto beat him fair and square, doesnt matter if it was MSG the right guy won the fight.

Come back when you have a sensable reply, not this ****** Mosley>>>>>Cotto because Mosley Kod Margarito. thats really ******!!!!!!!!!!

mosley > cotto.

mosley/cotto was a close fight in msg so other factors need to be considered like mosley beat margo who made cotto quit.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

mosley > cotto.

mosley/cotto was a close fight in msg so other factors need to be considered like mosley beat margo who made cotto quit.

You forgot to Mantion margo was plasterless against Mosley!!!!

By Your Logic

Mayorga>>>>>>Mosley because Mayorga KOd Forrest in 3, and Forrest beat Mosley!!!!!

That sa ****** logic dude.

Cotto beat Mosley and now beat the #3 WW. Cotto is above of Mosley right now!!!!!!!!!!!

[Iceta]

I have no clue why Vasquez, Marquez, Caballero, and Cotto are ranked in the top ten. Paul Williams belongs in the top 5 even though I think Mosley does too. Williams holds a dominant victory over the guy who had Shane's number and he beat the fresher version of Margarito. Also, Mosley absolutely refuses to fight Williams.

[Chups]

I always back the RING magazine up. They're the most credible. Mistakes can happen but rarely.

[THRILLA77]

the only thing i agree on is the number 1 and number 2 pound for pound but the rest of the list is terrible.....