Ring magazine Pound for pound? AGREE?

[blind4]

First of all He is the only one who gave pacquiao all he could handle as of recent . 2nd his first appearance at lighweight he knocks Casamayor out. then knocks out a Young lion name Juan Diaz at 35 years old. Best boxer skill wise up there with FMJ.

You will see when cotto goes down in Nov. how tough JMM is to go 24 rounds with the pacman and only lose by 1 point with both fight combined

Cotto is going to TKO Paquiao

[Sin City]

morons, wtf has jmm done to get up to #2 on that list?

he just unified lightweight

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

nah, cotto can't be #1. as is, he isn't good enough, but w/ a better trainer he could be.

Cotto just beat the #3 Ww and Holds a win over Mosley, So he should be ahead of Mosley as a WW and in the P4P rankings.

If Cotto beats Pacquiao he should be rank #2 or #3 p4P, definetly not #1. JMM should be ranked #1. Now if JMM Loses and cotto beats Pacquiao Cotto should be rank #1 P4P!!!!!!

[baracuda]

Cotto is going to TKO Paquiao

maybe,but there's also a big possibility that pac ko/tkos cotto.....it' a 50/50 fight...

[Sin City]

I think Shane Mosley should be higher on that list then Hopkins.
Mosley's win against Margarito is a far bigger accomplishment then Hopkins win against a blown up Pavlik.

[Sin City]

pound 4 pound rankings are based on speculation and pure opinion anyway.. they are hypothetical therefor bull****.. so who gives a ****? they mean NOTHING.

[MR ITALIAN]

Cotto just beat the #3 Ww and Holds a win over Mosley, So he should be ahead of Mosley as a WW and in the P4P rankings.

If Cotto beats Pacquiao he should be rank #2 or #3 p4P, definetly not #1. JMM should be ranked #1. Now if JMM Loses and cotto beats Pacquiao Cotto should be rank #1 P4P!!!!!!

What 3 WWs has he beat that would put him there...other than one close fight to Mosley

[BoxingChaos]

What happen to Counterfeit Money Mayweather Jr?

And Floyd trying to argue with Brian Kenny about him still being the pound for pound king, what an ass clown. Er, em' No, Floyd! You are the former and now you are not even on the list

Whooopppsssssiieeeee!

[Pullcounter]

yea....but cotto beat mosley, but i'm ok with the rankings as long as floyd is not present. If floyd beats marquez or anyone top welterweight then floyd can be on list. This is top p4p NOW, not 2 yrs ago.

yeah, but cotto only decisioned mosley in a close fight in MSG.

cotto quit against margo and mosley destroyed margo. that makes Mosley > cotto until cotto beats mosley in a rematch.

I agree here... now lets look at this the other way... how far down will Manny go if he looses to Cotto?

considering cotto will outweigh pac by 10 lbs on fight night, manny won't drop too low.

Golden Boy owns the ring Dude.

They ahve to make mosley look better or more deserving of what he is, so he can land the big fights and not COtto.

Cotto should be #1 at WW and #6 P4P. Mosley shouldbe #2 WW and #7 P4P

nah mosley is #1 and cotto is #2. mosley is the daddy of cotto's daddy.

[Easy-E]

What Vic and Callerbo are doing on that list is beyond me.