WTF? Ring Magazine Ratings

[Iceta]

Because Cotto hasn't done anyting impressive. Mosley was robbed againt him, Margarito beat him to a pulp, and Clottey was robbed against him. Give me something better than Gomez and Jennings.

[Rubber Duck]

The Ring take the official out come AFAIK, or rather knew. Moving down two positions is roughly what happpened to Cotto for an actual loss. This time he wins and goes down 2 again. I agree, WTF.

Cotto didnt do anything devastating. Some feel it could of went both ways and some feel he lost. When i say some it refers to fans and boxing experts. So he got a win. Thats all. SD dont cut it. Im sure if he went in there and made a mark he would of not been moved. IMO

[ИATAS]

I mean WTF Donaire has done in his career beside beating Darchinyan??????

Beat the **** out of three highly ranked fighters.

TKO'd Raul Martinez (24-0) in 4 rounds.
TKO'd Moruti Mthalane (22-1) in 6 rounds.
TKO'd Luis Maldonado (35-2) in 8 rounds.

And of course his win over Darchinyan is huge, considering how Vic has never lost another fight and has completely dominated his last few opponents.

[ИATAS]

If you say so man. I do agree it can be due to the style but it wouldn't of been a blowout against an Active Winky.

he may have won a couple more rounds but I think Williams takes care of Winky any time.

But I don't really care, you can insert several different guys at #10 that I wouldn't have a problem with.

[Kris Silver]

Because Cotto hasn't done anyting impressive. Mosley was robbed againt him, Margarito beat him to a pulp, and Clottey was robbed against him. Give me something better than Gomez and Jennings.

Consensus is Cotto beat Mosley, beat Clottey.

A lot think Marg had illegal wraps versus him.

Aside from them, better than Gomez and Jennings, ok...how about Judah, Malignaggi, Torres, and N'dou. Grow up mang, and stop being a hater.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Ring is slowly starting to become a joke. Ever since Golden Boy got its grubby hands on it

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Beat the **** out of three highly ranked fighters.

TKO'd Raul Martinez (24-0) in 4 rounds.
TKO'd Moruti Mthalane (22-1) in 6 rounds.
TKO'd Luis Maldonado (35-2) in 8 rounds.

And of course his win over Darchinyan is huge, considering how Vic has never lost another fight and has completely dominated his last few opponents.

Simply LOl Who the **** is Raul Martinez? Mathale was kicking Donaires ass, till Donaire started bitching to the ref to stop the fight do to Mathlanes Cut.

Donaire is not top 10 P4P yet, he have a long way to go!!!!!!

[-Hyperion-]

ridiculous especially considering how cotto outclassed #4(and im a huge shane fan)

[Mr. Fantastic]

Ring is slowly starting to become a joke. Ever since Golden Boy got its grubby hands on it

In a way you're right. I don't see how Hopkins is rated so high and he's 3-3 in his last 6 fights, plus he doesn't have a belt lol.

[ИATAS]

Ring is slowly starting to become a joke. Ever since Golden Boy got its grubby hands on it

Post your top ten, let's see what it should look like then...