Cotto -vs- Clottey.. Who won Poll?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • DrewWoodside
    Lifestyle..Regular!
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Jan 2008
    • 9244
    • 317
    • 590
    • 16,453

    #11
    Originally posted by KittenFlaps
    Clottey probably won, Cotto did win. Clottey can only blame himself, he should have known better than to keep it that close when he had every opportunity to pull so far ahead he couldn't have possibly lost.
    I have a feeling if Clottey had any more in the tank he would have given it. A lot of people are saying he should have known better but to be honest Clottey frequently gasses. Odds are, he was a lot more winded than anyone realizes. I doubt it was a matter of laziness but an inability to dig any deeper.

    Comment

    • The Hammer
      Banned
      Franchise Champion - 20,000+ posts
      • Dec 2007
      • 50797
      • 3,416
      • 8,704
      • 58,851

      #12
      I scored it 114-113 for Cotto.

      Comment

      • DrewWoodside
        Lifestyle..Regular!
        Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
        • Jan 2008
        • 9244
        • 317
        • 590
        • 16,453

        #13
        Originally posted by ~Tunney
        I scored it 114-113 for Cotto.
        Awe **** it. I'm tearing up my card then.. Jk. We can agree on this one.

        Comment

        • KittenFlaps
          Punch Drunk
          Platinum Champion - 1,000-5,000 posts
          • May 2009
          • 1252
          • 59
          • 38
          • 7,414

          #14
          Originally posted by DrewWoodside
          I have a feeling if Clottey had any more in the tank he would have given it. A lot of people are saying he should have known better but to be honest Clottey frequently gasses. Odds are, he was a lot more winded than anyone realizes. I doubt it was a matter of laziness but an inability to dig any deeper.
          I agree totally. I only mean the "he should have known better" in that he shouldn't feel so robbed seeing as he really didn't blatantly win a fight he should have known he had to blatantly win.

          Comment

          • Deja_Vous
            Banned
            • Mar 2009
            • 4279
            • 132
            • 0
            • 4,458

            #15
            Originally posted by wXh
            COTTO WON 114-113. I had the exact same scorecard as Lederman. Clottey didn't do enough in the final rounds to win the fight. PERIOD!
            Cotto did even less than Clottey.

            LOL

            Clottey landed more punches....set the pace...showed effective aggression..and a good scoring jab.

            Clottey won.

            Comment

            • ACHlLLES
              watch ur mouth
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Aug 2008
              • 8398
              • 236
              • 359
              • 15,211

              #16
              Originally posted by Deja_Vous
              Cotto did even less than Clottey.

              LOL

              Clottey landed more punches....set the pace...showed effective aggression..and a good scoring jab.

              Clottey won.
              Wheres the picture of him landing his clean jab like Cotto did? Looks to me it was Cotto who landed the cleaner looking jabs. If thats not the case, where are the pics of Clottey landing his jabs on Cotto?

              Comment

              • 120
                Lords of BoxingScene
                Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                • May 2008
                • 6264
                • 416
                • 799
                • 13,757

                #17
                Originally posted by intoccabile
                One thing I've noticed.. Boxingscene is very heavy on hispanics.
                Polls like this will never be accurate.

                There's 3 groups.
                Pacman groupies
                Cotto groupies
                Mayweather groupies

                Should never have a poll with EITHER of those 3 men.

                Oh, and over at fightjudge.com,

                "real" fans who judged the fight as it occured had Clottey winning. Check it out. It's definitely a more accurate look than your poll. You can see a higher % had Clottey winning 114-113.
                actually the scene is influenced by a lot of races and ethnics groups. there is a big European community, specially from Great Britain, the hispanic community is mostly mexican and puertorican but there are also dominicans, panamanians and others. anyways, all i'm saying is that u are generalizing and stereotyping...

                Comment

                • lizard_man
                  Undisputed Champion
                  • Jul 2008
                  • 2596
                  • 369
                  • 20
                  • 48,631

                  #18
                  Originally posted by BlackSilk
                  I say this.

                  Clottey doesn't deserve to win because he new what was at stake and let left his faith in the judges hand. Cotto doesn't deserve to win because he he let Clottey back into fight after the knock down. It should be a draw and know one walks away with a lost.

                  The fight is scored off conecting shots period. Looking at the fight again, and looking at the connecting shots, I gave it to Clottey. You can't give a fighter a round just because it was little to know action. I don't care how bizzy a fighter is, if he's not connectiong you shouldn't give him points. I don't believe boxing is scoring arm punches. I gave cotto the 1st, hard to score the 6th and gave him the 12. Thats just going of what I seen. Another thing the side live team was saying. When Cotto was getting beat most of the round and end it with a good shots, the was saying (Maybe Cotto stole that round) Off of one good shot, Please. I thought it was, who ever landed the most punches.

                  Thats my thoughts on that. They have the fight on Youtube.


                  how is the 6th round hard to score? that was a lopsided round in favor of cotto.

                  Comment

                  • DrewWoodside
                    Lifestyle..Regular!
                    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
                    • Jan 2008
                    • 9244
                    • 317
                    • 590
                    • 16,453

                    #19
                    Originally posted by Deja_Vous
                    Cotto did even less than Clottey.

                    LOL

                    Clottey landed more punches....set the pace...showed effective aggression..and a good scoring jab.

                    Clottey won.
                    Overall punch stats need to be taken with a grain of salt. In addition to the fact that fights aren't won with compubox. Each round needs to be scored individually, ultimately leading to a final score.

                    Comment

                    • Deja_Vous
                      Banned
                      • Mar 2009
                      • 4279
                      • 132
                      • 0
                      • 4,458

                      #20
                      Originally posted by ACHlLLES
                      Wheres the picture of him landing his clean jab like Cotto did? Looks to me it was Cotto who landed the cleaner looking jabs. If thats not the case, where are the pics of Clottey landing his jabs on Cotto?
                      Look at the first 3 rounds..

                      Clottey was wearing Cotto's ass out with his jab.

                      Clottey won that fight...

                      Effective aggresion..landed more..set the pace.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      TOP