Do you rank PBF a great WW?

[Toney Loc]

my bad......................................green K...............

It's all good.

[Horus]

what says you?...........................

How would you grade Mayweather run at Welterweight?
A+ = Greatest ever.
A = 2nd Greatest ever
A-= Greatest of His era
B+= Great (ring champion) and he was undisputed
B= He Did what he had to do to be recognize champ of the ww ( ring belt)
B-= He was the man, but he could have done more.
C+= He beat the man, and that's it.
C= Average
C-= Good
D+= Paper Champ
D= Below Average
D-=Worst than Paper Champ
F= Worst Champion he could possibly be.

[Toney Loc]

How would you grade Mayweather run at Welterweight?
A+ = Greatest ever.
A = 2nd Greatest ever
A-= Greatest of His era
B+= Great (ring champion) and he was undisputed
B= He Did what he had to do to be recognize champ of the ww ( ring belt)
B-= He was the man, but he could have done more.
C+= He beat the man, and that's it.
C= Average
C-= Good
D+= Paper Champ
D= Below Average
D-=Worst than Paper Champ
F= Worst Champion he could possibly be.

B or B- using that criteria.

[RightCross94]

he hasnt done nearly enough at WW to be considered a great fighter there, but at SFW and p4p he is a great fighter

[RightCross94]

How would you grade Mayweather run at Welterweight?
A+ = Greatest ever.
A = 2nd Greatest ever
A-= Greatest of His era
B+= Great (ring champion) and he was undisputed
B= He Did what he had to do to be recognize champ of the ww ( ring belt)
B-= He was the man, but he could have done more.
C+= He beat the man, and that's it.
C= Average
C-= Good
D+= Paper Champ
D= Below Average
D-=Worst than Paper Champ
F= Worst Champion he could possibly be.

probably a C+ or a B- minus going by that

i love floyd, and i think he cops too much crap around here but im not deluded, his WW run was solid but not great, his real greatness lies in what he did at 130 and 135

[strugler]

How would you grade Mayweather run at Welterweight?
A+ = Greatest ever.
A = 2nd Greatest ever
A-= Greatest of His era
B+= Great (ring champion) and he was undisputed
B= He Did what he had to do to be recognize champ of the ww ( ring belt)
B-= He was the man, but he could have done more.
C+= He beat the man, and that's it.
C= Average
C-= Good
D+= Paper Champ
D= Below Average
D-=Worst than Paper Champ
F= Worst Champion he could possibly be.

hey horus....................how do you rank his JWW run?...........................

[Klitschko2011]

Floyd is a coward, he ducked all the top welterweights and is now going after smaller fighters. Dude is a straight up *****.

[strugler]

Floyd is a coward, he ducked all the top welterweights and is now going after smaller fighters. Dude is a straight up *****.

so ..................you dont think his an ATG in WW?.....................LOL

[Toney Loc]

Floyd is a coward, he ducked all the top welterweights and is now going after smaller fighters. Dude is a straight up *****.

This thread was going well...

[nujabes77]

he's best @ lw. wouldn't consider him a great ww until he proves it