Do you rank PBF a great WW?

[strugler]

Horus still there?............................................

[Benny Leonard]

Not at WW. His best weights was from 130-140. He hasn't really proved that much at WW.

I've actually thought about making a thread like this as well. I want to see what everybody thinks of each fighters ATG status as far as each division they fought in. Could they compete with other ATG fighters in each division they fought at?

Floyd from 130-154

Pac from 106-147

Etc. Etc. Etc.

[Benny Leonard]

Nope. Not even close.

he was a ATG JLW tho and a ATG overall.

But the only division he was a ATG was 130, maybe 135!!
He fiught the majority of his fights at LW tho!!!!!!!!!

130-140 I think he is an ATG and could fight other Top Fighters and ATG fighters in those divisions.

For 147+....different story and it is wide-open for speculation.

[strugler]

130-140 I think he is an ATG and could fight other Top Fighters and ATG fighters in those divisions.

For 147+....different story and it is wide-open for speculation.

even at 140?.....................based on what fight benny?...............

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

130-140 I think he is an ATG and could fight other Top Fighters and ATG fighters in those divisions.

For 147+....different story and it is wide-open for speculation.

WTF he did at 35 beside beating JLC and WTF he did at 140? I mean Bruseles, gatti, Corley makes yiu a ATG in that division? WTF?

Dude is a SFW ATG for sure, teh rest of teh divisions he fought in, **** no!!!!!!!!!!

[Benny Leonard]

even at 140?.....................based on what fight benny?...............

His skill level.

[Silencers]

No........

[strugler]

His skill level.

LMAO...................a hypothesis......................a subjective conclusion.................thats where we differ......................resume trumps percieved skills any day of the week................................

[Benny Leonard]

WTF he did at 35 beside beating JLC and WTF he did at 140? I mean Bruseles, gatti, Corley makes yiu a ATG in that division? WTF?

Dude is a SFW ATG for sure, teh rest of teh divisions he fought in, **** no!!!!!!!!!!

As far as putting him up against other ATG in those divisions is what I'm saying. As far as ATG status...no.

140 wasn't really his fault though. You think he was going to wait around for Hatton to be "read" to fight him?


It is Floyd's fault for moving up to fast. He wanted O$car and it cost him in a way.

[Benny Leonard]

LMAO...................a hypothesis......................a subjective conclusion.................thats where we differ......................resume trumps percieved skills any day of the week................................

Seriously; Why do use so many .................................................. .................................................. .................................................. .................................................. .................................................. .................................................. .................................................. .................................................. ..........................................?