Joe Calzaghe was on of the true greats

[P4P GOAT]

Ottke was a true great

Ottke would have beaten holyfield. he was a level below Ottke.

Lennox Lewis is a more difficult fight to pick but he would have trouble with a prime Ottke hand speed.

Tyson would of been a pick em fight

I beat up 100 girls and now my record is 100-0. I am better than Calzaghe because I have more wins in my unbeaten record regardless of who I fought. I am unbeaten, that makes me great.

Ottke and Calzaghe ? good comparison

[El_Cholo]

twoshe lol sadly i dont remmember, but i dont think it would have mattered what wight floyd fought him, floyd was just better.

I don't dispute that I just feel Hatton is natural light welter

[portuge puncher]

I don't dispute that I just feel Hatton is natural light welter

i geuss you are right.
but notheless i still think floyd's resume is better then calzaghe's.

[Chr0nic]

Ottke and Calzaghe ? good comparison

atleast ottke fought glen johnson

[El_Cholo]

i geuss you are right.
but notheless i still think floyd's resume is better then calzaghe's.

that is down to Joe's injuries, fighters ducking him and Warren not getting him the right fights imo.

[P4P GOAT]

atleast ottke fought glen johnson

Ottke stayed in germany and lost fights but still won decisions. There is no comparison between Joe's resume and his. Joe actually beat the guys he faced.

[portuge puncher]

that is down to Joe's injuries, fighters ducking him and Warren not getting him the right fights imo.

true, but nevertheless, his resume is lackluster, and he isnt an ATG, but he'll be a HOFer.

[Chr0nic]

Ottke stayed in germany and lost fights but still won decisions. There is no comparison between Joe's resume and his. Joe actually beat tehe guys he faced.

what about reid?
and unlike most people i believe joe beat hopkins, but reid on the other hand

[El_Cholo]

true, but nevertheless, his resume is lackluster, and he isnt an ATG, but he'll be a HOFer.

I'n not dis*****g where he will be placed in future years it's those posters that claim he fought nobodies for 10 years.

most of whom seem to be ignorant Americans who have no knowledge of Joe's career and circumstances.

[portuge puncher]

I'n not dis*****g where he will be placed in future years it's those posters that claim he fought nobodies for 10 years.

most of whom seem to be ignorant Americans who have no knowledge of Joe's career and circumstances.

for a while he did fight nobodies, but now that i think about it, every fighter has at one point fought nobodies, the man in my avatar, JCC, has loads of nobodies on his record, along with some greats.

joe had some great wins, like Eubank, Lacy, Hopkins, his best IMO being kessler.

but your right, there is an awful lot of hate on him, personally im not a huge fan of his, but now that i think about it, he's alright, and hasent really done anything to deserive all this hate.