is mayweather #1 p4p if he beats jmm?

[strugler]

NO.....................if he fought him at 140............he would have a credible case............

[**********]

I'm not into triangle theories but. Pacquiao beat Marquez already so his value isn't much. So Floyd beating Marquez doesn't really change anything. Pacquiao will still be the #1 P4P. Floyd might not even get into the P4P rankings with a win over a LW.

[shogunn]

ask Floyd whos P4P. Floyd: "Who beat me!...*clap clap* who beat me!"

[fallenloki]

How many ****ing threads do we need on this same thing?

[DGP]

floyd cant be pound for pound until he beats real welterweights such as cotto mosley clottey not paq or marquez. how can you be the welter champ and not fight one top welter.

[Equinox]

he was p4-p #1 for years. no body beat him. he retired. hes coming back to ko jmm the #2 p4p. how does that not get you back to your rightful position?

[Don Flamenco]

Beating PAC and JMM just proves he beats the smaller man. Why don't we have a matchup of David haye Vs. Manny, then JMM and David Haye can be #1 p4p.

Pretty boy needs to clean out 147 to be #1.