How good is Floyd's resume?

[Pullcounter]

c'mon puerto ricans... floyd only option after jmm is to fight mosley. if the arum/floyd feud ruins a fight with pac (which is a huge huge fight), it will ruin a fight w/ cotto.

if floyd beats jmm and mosley, that should be enough.

[BmoreBrawler]

Discuss....

Poll to be added.

he has a solid resume, just not comparable to the top40 ATG's. Just because he is ducking ppl now does not mean that he always did.

[D-Omonist]

c'mon puerto ricans... floyd only option after jmm is to fight mosley. if the arum/floyd feud ruins a fight with pac (which is a huge huge fight), it will ruin a fight w/ cotto.

if floyd beats jmm and mosley, that should be enough.

I am not overlooking JMM, but after he beats him, he would need to fight at least two elite fighters to gain maximum respect. Mosley alone would be good, but Mosley and Cotto or Mosley/Pac would be better.

[-EX-]

I would love to see Cotto and him go at it, but to say Mosley is past his prime is not correct. Dude seems to be at his peak! More respect.

Nah mayne. Shane will be 38 later this year. He didn't look good against Mayorga. He seemed a little winded against Cotto(maybe the body shots). He's still a top fighter but no way is he at his peak.

[Burner]

I am not overlooking JMM, but after he beats him, he would need to fight at least two elite fighters to gain maximum respect. Mosley alone would be good, but Mosley and Cotto or Mosley/Pac would be better.

He aint fighting Cotto AND Mosley......

Its JMM.

Pacman.

Cotto or Mosley

[Smash]

maybe but I still know way more than you will ever know. You come in and try to say something that comes off as intelligent but in reality comes off as nothing more than a surface level pass at really breaking down why you feel that way then when someoen calls you on it you do nothing more than make a broad statement and turn it on me or whoever you are debating with in a feeble attempt to get away from the point you made

comparing Baldo to the likes of Chico and JLC is all I needed to read to make this assumption as anyone with any knowledge of the sport would know the careers of Baldomir and both Chico and JLC and would summize that his pales in comparison. Even Judah, who I think is closer than Baldo would ever be, is still a notch or two below the above mentioned.

so tell me why you think both are in the same league as Baldomir and Judah. Dont just make some broad statement tell me why you think that

Ill explain again for the hard of learning. I said corrales and castillo are closer to juddah and baldo than the likes of floyd and pac and you and el ******o throw your rattlers out of your prams. Did you read my previous post where i mentioned numbers to explain to el ******o, it may be basic but i hoped even the hard of learning could understand it.

Maybe your angry because i dont agree that your two boys should be in the hof. I never said that juddah was better than them i just think they fall short of the top elite guys.

[D-Omonist]

Nah mayne. Shane will be 38 later this year. He didn't look good against Mayorga. He seemed a little winded against Cotto(maybe the body shots). He's still a top fighter but no way is he at his peak.

All I know is at 38 I would like to have his conditioning.

[D-Omonist]

He aint fighting Cotto AND Mosley......

Its JMM.

Pacman.

Cotto or Mosley

I'm thinking the same thing.

After he beats JMM. It would be:

Pacman....then retire.

Or

Cotto...then retire. Not likely though.

Or

Mosley...then retire. Might happen.

[sunny31]

maybe but I still know way more than you will ever know. You come in and try to say something that comes off as intelligent but in reality comes off as nothing more than a surface level pass at really breaking down why you feel that way then when someoen calls you on it you do nothing more than make a broad statement and turn it on me or whoever you are debating with in a feeble attempt to get away from the point you made

comparing Baldo to the likes of Chico and JLC is all I needed to read to make this assumption as anyone with any knowledge of the sport would know the careers of Baldomir and both Chico and JLC and would summize that his pales in comparison. Even Judah, who I think is closer than Baldo would ever be, is still a notch or two below the above mentioned.

so tell me why you think both are in the same league as Baldomir and Judah. Dont just make some broad statement tell me why you think that

I don't think judah is a notch or 2 below castillo or corrales, that is over-stated. He is probably on that level. Chico is a 2 weight world champ, as is judah. Castillo was a top notch lw in his prime. It is hard for me to separate them to be honest. They have all fought some of the best fighters in and around their weight class.

[El Dominicano]

maybe but I still know way more than you will ever know. You come in and try to say something that comes off as intelligent but in reality comes off as nothing more than a surface level pass at really breaking down why you feel that way then when someoen calls you on it you do nothing more than make a broad statement and turn it on me or whoever you are debating with in a feeble attempt to get away from the point you made

comparing Baldo to the likes of Chico and JLC is all I needed to read to make this assumption as anyone with any knowledge of the sport would know the careers of Baldomir and both Chico and JLC and would summize that his pales in comparison. Even Judah, who I think is closer than Baldo would ever be, is still a notch or two below the above mentioned.

so tell me why you think both are in the same league as Baldomir and Judah. Dont just make some broad statement tell me why you think that

Don't waste your time, I'm real close to adding him to my ignore list. What a dumb ass he is