How good is Floyd's resume?

[HandSpeed303]

that is one ******ed poll.

Only had to go three post in to hear the truth.....

[Eaner0919]

I would take Oscar to dismantle even at that stage of his career any of Floyd's previous opponents

p4p?

ok I'll bite break it down

[Smash]

you really think either one of them might not get in?

based on?

Their records

Chico was a very good fighter who had some good wins against casamayor and castillo but other than that im struggling to remember other noteably wins
He was very entertaining alrite but pretty easy to hit. Personally i think he falls short of hof standard, what do you think?

Castillo in his prime was a very good fighter but then again if you let him in there may be a lot of fighters saying, hold on, what about me then?
Again, what do you think?

[boojee]

Good enough to propell Pacman to at least #3 ALL TIME GREAT after he knocks mayweather out (and cotto)

[D-Omonist]

Only had to go three post in to hear the truth.....

The pool may seem ******ed at first, but it shows that Floyd is not better than Pac, Mosley and many ATG's. Although, the majority is saying his resume is Garbage too. Anywayz svck a d!ck up until ya hickup!!!

[Benny Leonard]

Their records

Chico was a very good fighter who had some good wins against casamayor and castillo but other than that im struggling to remember other noteably wins
He was very entertaining alrite but pretty easy to hit. Personally i think he falls short of hof standard, what do you think?

Castillo in his prime was a very good fighter but then again if you let him in there may be a lot of fighters saying, hold on, what about me then?
Again, what do you think?

Chico broke down Freitas and Acelino never seemed the same after that. Acelino showed heart in every fight up to that point...remember Barrios fight?

[D-Omonist]

Good enough to propell Pacman to at least #3 ALL TIME GREAT after he knocks mayweather out (and cotto)

And you think he will knock out May and Cotto! We betting if he fights them.

[-EX-]

Better than Cotto's...

[Google_It_Bitch]

Considering I collect fights, I don't try to own any of PBF's fights. It will be the one fighter whom I wont bother trying to get his career set. Enough said.
:PAZ:

[Eaner0919]

Their records

Chico was a very good fighter who had some good wins against casamayor and castillo but other than that im struggling to remember other noteably wins
He was very entertaining alrite but pretty easy to hit. Personally i think he falls short of hof standard, what do you think?

I think you may have not watched enough Chico to understand that not only does he have enough top tier wins (Casamayor, Castillo, Freitas) but is also a three time two division champion. He also has enough second tier wins (guys like Gainer Manfredy Garcia etc) for me to say he is a lock be in the hall. Maybe not first tier but he will be close

Castillo in his prime was a very good fighter but then again if you let him in there may be a lot of fighters saying, hold on, what about me then?
Again, what do you think?

cmon do you even know these guys bodies of work?

Casamayor
Corrales
Johnston

all good solid wins against champs or upper tier guys

two time lightweight champion of the world

and he has enough second tier wins (Bazan, Lazacano (a slept on war), Julio Diaz, Reyes) IMO to make this a lock. Again like Chico he may not be first ballot BUT they he is in for sure.


also in comparison to some of the others who are in its clear both of these guys deserve to be in the hall