Since 2005, who tested PBF's chin???

[larry x]

Did Mitchell catch him clean? I don't really remember that too clearly. I thought Floyd pretty much dominated him, but he gave an okay showing for being above his natural weight and pretty far past his prime.

Mitchell caught Williams a lot, but... what rounds did he get Mayweather in?

yep at the end of round 2

[letsgobrady]

corrales caught floyd wit a straight right,castillo caught him with a mean left hook,zab caght him with a straight left and oscar caught him with a left hook in the last round and floyd never really ever seemed phased by anyof those punches or anyone for that matter,and as far as knocking floyd out lets be serious, has anyone knocked out hopkins? has anyone knocked out james toney? has anyone knocked out pernell whitaker? these are all superb defensive fighters and will never get knocked out so get over it

[MaFu MoFo]

What about Floyd screams Ricky Hatton?

This thread fails.

Floyd has taken punches from Oscar when he weighed over 160 pounds...And Judah at 147 who hit harder then Pac does.

Uhh! Whatever you mean with the scream... anyway I believe that PAC hits harder than Judah.

[larry x]

Uhh! Whatever you mean with the scream... anyway I believe that PAC hits harder than Judah.

naw i dont think so

[Fox McCloud]

Uhh! Whatever you mean with the scream... anyway I believe that PAC hits harder than Judah.

He clearly does...

and even if he doesn't... it doesn't matter, because he can hurt you with a combination and is not the worst finisher in the sport (that title belongs to Judah), so... the power factor swings Pacquiao's way regardless.

[letsgobrady]

Uhh! Whatever you mean with the scream... anyway I believe that PAC hits harder than Judah.

floyd has never seemed hurt ever in his career even the corley punch didn't really seem to do much it just stopped floyd for a couple of seconds then floyd started to counter punch the **** out of corley where as pacquiao has seemed hurt a couple of times by smaller men than floyd

[MaFu MoFo]

THREAD REVIEW:

Castillo and Corley tested PBF before 2005.

ODLH tested PBF since he ladned a couple of clean shots and weighted 160lbs. (?).


THE NEW QUESTION: How powerful was Oscar's punch when he fought PBF???

We know ODLH has a great jab, but I am talking about power punching. I believe that at the later part of his career, Oscar needed to constantly punish an opponent in order to cause damage. Before ODLH KO on Mayorgas, his last significant win by KO was againt Vargas in 2002. I am not counting his KOs agaisnt Gatti and Campas (for the record).

[MaFu MoFo]

naw i dont think so

Fine, I am not going to argue with you. It's only an opinion.

[letsgobrady]

He clearly does...

and even if he doesn't... it doesn't matter, because he can hurt you with a combination and is not the worst finisher in the sport (that title belongs to Judah), so... the power factor swings Pacquiao's way regardless.

yea and floyd gets caught with alot of combinations right, zab is obviously the harder puncher,besides hatton who has manny really seem to hurt with 1 punch, zab has plenty of fights where that straight left or that left upprcut leaves his opponents on ***** street manny has to land alot of punches to hurt his opponents and even if you look at fights like the marquez fight he drops marquez 3 times then marquez wins almost every round after that if that was zab judah after 2 knockdowns the fight would most likely be over

[Fox McCloud]

floyd has never seemed hurt ever in his career even the corley punch didn't really seem to do much it just stopped floyd for a couple of seconds then floyd started to counter punch the **** out of corley where as pacquiao has seemed hurt a couple of times by smaller men than floyd

He was at least buzzed against Corley and Judah... he doesn't stumble back into the ropes for fun or as part of his strategy after all... that punch did a lot of damage in both cases.

THREAD REVIEW:

Castillo and Corley tested PBF before 2005.

ODLH tested PBF since he ladned a couple of clean shots and weighted 160lbs. (?).


THE NEW QUESTION: How powerful was Oscar's punch when he fought PBF???

We know ODLH has a great jab, but I am talking about power punching. I believe that at the later part of his career, Oscar needed to constantly punish an opponent in order to cause damage. Before ODLH KO on Mayorgas, his last significant win by KO was againt Vargas in 2002. I am not counting his KOs agaisnt Gatti and Campas (for the record).

Oscar landed a left hook and the Judah straight left was flush and knocked Floyd's head way back.

Also, the ODLH KO on Mayorga was the fight immediately before Mayorga, so he clearly did have at least some power left.

I do think it was diminished from where it was early in his career though... plus it was in the 12th, after he had faded.

But really, other than Oscar, which did test it some, Judah clearly tested his chin.