better counter puncher, marquez or mayweather?

[nujabes77]

my first poll, hope this **** works

[El Dominicano]

my first poll, hope this **** works

Defense and counter punching go hand in hand. You can't be the best counter puncher without being a good or great defensive fighter, neither can you be the best defensive fighter without being a good or great counter puncher.

Mayweather, B-Hop >> JMM in counter punching. We ain't gonna act like JMM doesn't get hit in return

[Mersey]

Floyd is better imo

[nujabes77]

Defense and counter punching go hand in hand. You can't be the best counter puncher without being a good or great defensive fighter, neither can you be the best defensive fighter without being a good or great counter puncher.

Mayweather, B-Hop >> JMM in counter punching. We ain't gonna act like JMM doesn't get hit in return

just talking about counter punching ability exclusively. not defense

[Mersey]

just talking about counter punching ability exclusively. not defense

But Floyd would be more effective as he's not getting hit in the process.

[El Dominicano]

just talking about counter punching ability exclusively. not defense

Sorry but you can't talk about counter punching, without talking about defense.

[Technical_Skill]

Mayweather, look at the technique on the Hatton left hook, crazy, moving backwards, timed perfectly, and even turned off the ropes whilst doing it, all in a few seconds.

[nujabes77]

But Floyd would be more effective as he's not getting hit in the process.

Sorry but you can't talk about counter punching, without talking about defense.

*sighs* ...

[Mersey]

*sighs* ...

Ok, just to make you happy. Let's not talk about the defensive part.

Floyd is a better counterpuncher still.

[Pugilistic™]

I would say Floyd is the better counterpuncher.