Is Cottos win over Mosley bigger then any win Mayweather has

[HitBattousai]

Cotto's win over Mosley is better than any single win that Floyd has at present.
Floyd's overall resume is better than Cotto's at present.

[GoAltYourFace]

BIGSHOW > mosley

end of thread

[Ravishing]

It's tough to put Cotto's win over Mosley over Floyd's win over Corrales simply because Corrales was supposed to put immense pressure on Floyd and he made it look like a sparring match for the most part.

But as of recent, Cotto's win over Mosley trumps anything Floyd's done possibly since then as far as being in a competitive fight and winning.

[Joe2608]

I believe it is better than any win Mayweather has had. Cotto took a match he could possibly lose and that was a major challenge. Mayweather has only fought people he knows he can beat.

[Pullcounter]

What do you say, its an opinion topic. I'm not going to debate anyone, I'll let the poll speak for itself.

cotto beating mosley is as good as floyd beating dlh

[baya]

of course - shane's a better opponent than anyone on mayweathers resume.

a prime chico better than a bit past his prime shane? nope.

jesus chavez? ODLH? hatton? haha. castillo is a good name but, nope.

so yeah, cotto has taken on the best man and beat him between these two resumes.

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

Yes, as a P4P fighter Mosley is the best opponent in both resumes.

While I agree with that staement above and I truly enjoyed watching the fight I still don't see it as a bigger accomplishment because there are many out there who would make a case that Shane won that fight....Lefty

[Little Killer]

Mosley just got owned by Winky and Forrest and he got a gift against Oscar at 154. Corrales was undefeated top 5 p4p fighter Floyd beat him in every single round

Also Mayweather performance was unquestionable. There is argument that Mosley earned a draw and the nod. The rematch should happen in the West Coast

[mellow_mood]

Mayweather's win against Diego > Cotto's win against Mosley..

one is a one sided domination of a prime undefeated borderline HOF the other one is a disputable win over a past prime HOF borderline ATG

chico is a hall of famer?

oh ok.. borderline....

[BOOMbip]

Mosley just got owned by Winky and Forrest and he got a gift against Oscar at 154. Corrales was undefeated top 5 p4p fighter Floyd beat him in every single round

Also Mayweather performance was unquestionable. There is argument that Mosley earned a draw and the nod. The rematch should happen in the West Coast

Yea cause in boxing the LOSER of the match gets to dictate the specifics of The REMATCH....wait no...it's the other way around.

If you lose a UD and you want a rematch....you be very humble and fight wherever your told and for less money.

Cause you can easily be put on the back burner for bigger pay days...

Thats what I feel has happened to Mosley...He has played himself into a corner with this 1 win over plasterless Margarito